News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Brief History of the End of the Comments by Animats on Friday October 09, 2015 @01:08AM (#10358291)
Here's an amusing example: Mozilla's blog no longer allows comments.[1] But they're asking for comments. So they write: "Tell us what you think of these proposed principles on your social channels using #contentblocking and join us on Friday October 9 at 11am PT for our #BlockParty, a conversation around the problems and possible solutions to the content blocking question." So they're sending people to Twitter to comment?

[1] https://blog.mozilla.org/blog/2015/10/07/proposed-principles...

Re:A Brief History of the End of the Comments by firebones on Friday October 09, 2015 @01:15AM (#10358309)
Benefit: any follower of that hashtag (including Mozilla) can block an offensive commenter (no need for universal moderation--you can choose whatever level of freedom/inanity/bile you wish.) Classic Clay Shirky "publish then filter" dynamics, with the crowd getting to tune their own personal filter.

That approach actually seems enlightened--commenters own their own comments, readers own their filters, and if Mozilla wishes, it can curate the best of the best and amplify (say, with retweets or something like Storify).

Re:A Brief History of the End of the Comments by Animats on Friday October 09, 2015 @04:10PM (#10362968)
At the designated time, there's a tiny amount of discussion under "#BlockParty" on Twitter, interspersed with big ads for hip-hop block parties. Mozilla isn't the only one using that tag.

On Facebook, it's not an item on the Firefox Facebook page, so you can't comment there.

Vine and Instagram have #BlockParty hits, none of which have anything to do with Mozilla.

Nothing on the Mozilla Governance mailing list.

"news.mozilla.org", Mozilla's USENET server, seems to be broken.

As a way to discuss the subject, this was a total fail.

Re:A Brief History of the End of the Comments by notahacker on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:09AM (#10358910)
Sounds like a smart idea to me. Instead of having their page clogged with comments (some of them probably snarky ones) they get a crowdsourced social media campaign. I don't think Twitter's a great medium for reasoned debate on principles, but I can see the appeal to the Mozilla Foundation.
Re:A Brief History of the End of the Comments by Animats on Friday October 09, 2015 @02:50PM (#10362464)
Yes. From the Foundation's perspective, it weakens opposition.
Re:A Brief History of the End of the Comments by welanes on Friday October 09, 2015 @03:57AM (#10358700)
Feels disjointed having to jump to another platform. Is it possible / would it be better to show the Twitter feed with that hashtag below the articles?