Can I ask what you mean by "really should be plenty"? I left out costs which, in my part of the country, would vastly exceed the remaining $1.2k in our little exercise. I guess I should have been explicit about this assumption. I am better off than the average American by far, but even so, student loans from my grad school (an extravagance, I know) hurt to the tune of $1k/month. I don't have kids, but feeding/clothing/sheltering them would take a pretty penny too, nevermind the costs to time, commute, etc.
Any one of the un-accounted-for expenses could vary wildly person to person, and could easily swallow up all that excess. I'm all for frugality and feel like folks have a lot to learn in that regard. Still, $52k for a household doesn't seem to math out without a whole lot of scrimping and luck.
Certainly there are places (SF in particular) where you're in a pretty bad place if you're making the national median, but I think anyone making the local median in those places is doing all right. The median is by definition not going to be a good place for keeping up worth the joneses. But if you opt out of the competitive things and just spend on what you need, I really think $52k is a pretty good place to be, and if you're struggling at that level (and aren't tied to a job in an expensive city) you should seriously look at downsizing your house/car/whatever your biggest expense is, because I have to wonder where all that money's going.
Of course plenty of people really are struggling - half of the country is on less than $52k after all. Below about $40k I'd definitely say "it's not you, it's your income" or something on those lines.
If you get a smaller house - say $1k/month - suddenly you can afford to live very comfortably, and save some as well. $52k is absolutely a lot of money; of course there's always more things to spend it on, and I won't pretend more money isn't very nice, but $52k really should be plenty. Putting it another way: if $52k isn't enough to make you happy, $100k probably won't be either.