This time they're both starting from zero, so it'll be very interesting to see who gains more market fighting on equal ground. (Perhaps the first time we see them in this situation?)
So, assuming that the article is accurate in this respect, I'm guessing that it won't be specifically Microsoft hardware.
They're less than that: they're a client/server software company. Their web applications, for all the Windows/Office revenue thrown at them, are still less mature than their competitors.
I also share the same sentiments towards Google and their recent hardware follies.
So, no, Xbox has not done 'pretty well'.
They are now 5 quarters profitable, but overall they're still in a very deep hole.
All this isn't to say that MS won't mess up the courier concept but that they're better than many people give them credit for.
All this is is a very transparent attempt at undercutting their competition, if the zune was any indication of how well they'll stack up then Apple has (unfortunately) very little to worry about.
What is much more interesting here is if there really is a market for these devices as large as is being predicted.