News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What is it like to have never felt an emotion? by SilasX on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @02:12PM (#10347797)
I agree, it sounds like this all just regresses to the qualia problem: "does my internal experience have the same attributes as yours?"

It reminds me of my inquiry into the mystery of why everyone "likes alcoholic drinks" but I don't. Eventually I broke it down into specific questions:

- Do you enjoy the feeling of alcoholic drinks passing through your mouth?

- Do you require the drink to be loaded down with non-alcohol flavors for it to be bearable?

- On taste alone, would you prefer a milkshake?

- Do you enjoy the feeling the drink produces on your mind? Does that matter to you more than the taste?

... and it turned out, I had the exact same answers to these questions as people who said they do like alcohol; it's just that they characterized that state as "liking alcohol", and I didn't.

If people similarly broke this issue down into specific questions on observables, I suspect a lot of the differences would vanish, and it would make more sense to characterize it as "different emotional response" rather than "no emotions" -- though a big part of the problem is the arbitrariness of the labels!

There are no comments on this comment yet.