Re:We're Replacing Comments with Something Better
by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @11:35AM
(#10339570)
I think I agree with your sentiment. I should have been more precise; I don't think all discussions should be done in an ephemeral, upvote-based format, but threaded discussion would be a big improvement for most of the old-style boards I participated in. Also, Reddit UI strikes the right balance between simplicity and functionality. Most boards are overloaded UI-wise.
I think there's a place for both, but the Reddit-style boards make every discussion ephemeral. No matter how interesting the topic or diverse the discussion, it's gone and forgotten in 2 days at most. On old-school boards, a major thread of discussion can last for months, or longer. Plus there's something to be said for a chronological presentation of posts. Yeah, trolls get more exposure, but it also means everyone sees every view (up to whatever the moderation policy of the site is), so you don't get the Reddit hivemind effect nearly as much.