News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We're Replacing Comments with Something Better by manigandham on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @04:54AM (#10337536)
How is HN any different than any other places? What's "right" about it?

It's just the general audience here is different but the technical details about commenting are exactly the same. You bring the mainstream audience here and you will end up with Reddit.

Re:We're Replacing Comments with Something Better by TuringTest on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @05:36AM (#10337696)
Attracting the right audience is a big part of making a good comment system...

Technical solutions are not enough by themselves to solve social problems. However, the threaded system, user moderation, and aggressive reputation enforcement are useful tools for keeping a healthy environment with a controlled volume of regular readers.

I'm not saying that this site could survive going mainstream - but right now it's an example of working user-generated commentary.

Re:We're Replacing Comments with Something Better by Eupolemos on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @06:33AM (#10337904)
Indeed.

But the thing is, of course, that you are framing your answer to not include the original case. In my book that is just a non-answer.

You even started out with "a funny" saying "look at this site you're reading". You didn't care if it fitted the case, you just wanted to say something clever. Very Reddit-like (and I do like Reddit).

But in what we could call an open environment where people do not care about their reputation - such as Vice - what can you do?

Re:We're Replacing Comments with Something Better by TuringTest on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @06:58AM (#10338019)
> You are framing your answer to not include the original case

That's your interpretation. I interpreted the original claim by erdojo that "User-generated commentary can be done right" as a general assertion that there are ways to achieve meaningful conversation, just like the one we're having now.

> In what we could call an open environment where people do not care about their reputation - such as Vice - what can you do?

Now you are framing the answer. If you want to know how to build a good comment system, my answer is "don't create an open environment where people do not care about their reputation".

If you find this to be a non-answer, maybe it's because I didn't reply to what you thought was the question - but that question had not been made explicit, so there was leeway in how to address it.

Re:We're Replacing Comments with Something Better by forgetsusername on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @06:34AM (#10337908)
>It's just the general audience here is different

It's not even the general audience. It's the subject matter, which is carefully selected.

HN is the best place on the internet for discussing a specific kind of subject, mainy technical matters, programming and the like. But post anything half-way political, and the comments look no better or more informed than anywhere else on the web. Which is why the moderation doesn't allow it.

Re:We're Replacing Comments with Something Better by oneeyedpigeon on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @06:16AM (#10337849)
It's so very different. Most comment sections don't have peer-moderation. Those that do (e.g. the Guardian) tend to not really penalise comments - in fact, the Guardian doesn't even have a 'downvote' concept. Even genuine rivals to HN (reddit, slashdot) tend to be much less strict on quality of comments. HN will punish you if you write too many comments that don't get strongly upvoted, and it's that kind of approach that helps to guarantee productive commentary.
Re:We're Replacing Comments with Something Better by kefka on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @06:50AM (#10337983)
Still, unless it's political.

Then half the "side" is upvoting, and the others are downvoting. Pick a topic like Taxes or regulation, and watch from the woodwork.