You're making the assumption that people want this.
They don't.
16 people post the same comment 45 seconds after the article goes online (without reading it properly).
8 people post more thoughtful but identical comments 15 minutes later.
I wake up 16 hours after the article goes online and post my tuppence worth into a rely to whatever is at the top. (without bothering to read the other 362 comments).
[Updated to fix rubbish formatting]
> You're making the assumption that people want this.
That might actually be a useful filter. The people out to cause trouble who seem to get off on the reaction to poor comments are more likely to be put off by the lack of immediacy than those who are more interested in a proper debate and take their time writing something well thought out and coherent.
They are, but only for you. They're still options for the author and everyone who hasn't opted out. That's what opting out means - your choice not to use a communication tool only affects you. The impact of your choice will be that you can't discuss something with the article's author directly.
If the editorial email address is swamped then they'll close it, or make it harder to find. That's all.
Made me consider a shared (fake) facebook account - one that would be used just for such interactions, shared among folks that are averse to creating an account themselves. Sharing the username-password combo itself would soon lend itself to trollish password reset attempts though, so perhaps there could be a service that accepts email and makes facebook posts on your behalf using its own account. The email format could be something like:
Type: Wall post [or "comment" or "private message"]
Page Url: <Vice's page>
Content: First!
Facebook (or whatever other service this is created for) would probably catch up with the profile sooner or later, but that just means time to move to a new fake profile. Given the amount of disregard these companies show for user privacy, I have no moral compunction against such "deception".Perhaps a weekend project for someone with this itch to scratch.
Saying "It'd be better if content sites didn't use FB!" is something that would have a detrimental impact on the web experience of more than a billion other people who have chosen not to opt out. That's something that you have to consider when you suggest an alternative solution.
For example, no SaaS startup should be writing their own payment system unless they're a fintech startup doing payments. If you're wasting time building things that you buy in for much lower cost then you will fail.
It also might serve as a place where people can think more about their responses knowing they will be given more credence and visibility instead of trying to respond with canned thoughts and knee-jerk reactions without really giving the conversation and their position much thought.
...Or, it can just turn out dead. Honestly, in this new age of more information and data than we can deal with, I personally have come to realize the value of curators, and although this might be a slippery slope in terms of hive-mind in that regard [one person deciding what's worth viewing for everyone] I think done well it can be pretty amazing.
Your editorial email address will be swamped for a while until people get bored with the lack of near-realtime debate.
"...our readers are best served by dedicating our resources to doing more reporting than attempting to police a comments section...".
That's why you appoint trusted moderators. Anyway, your 'resources' are now going to be split between processing email, visiting Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn...
We'll see.