From what users type in?
If so, and certain phrases get censored from autosuggest (even though "Islam is" is specifically in the censor list, it is not the only phrase that is specifically on this list), then my conclusion would be that the majority of phrases that googlers type in that start with "Islam is" are hateful? Hence the exclusion. In fact, what phrases get excluded might even be data driven as you can deduce sentiment from the most common phrases that users type in.
A lot of other "<something> is/are" terms are filtered too. I dont think this is specifically about offending Muslims.
It was groups of hardliners with their own agenda (aka not representing the religion) who, for the most part, provided the extreme reaction. The majority showed roughly the same response as to JS:TO.
I fear that things like Ireland's new blasphemy law, which came into force a few days ago, are the result of this trend. (Of course, it applies to mockery of all religions; in the West at least one can hardly get a law passed outlawing just mockery of Islam.)
I just read a comment elsewhere that such a trend "incentivises outrage", which I think is exactly right.