You could conceivably make it switchable so that you only cut out certain advertising networks.
MFA seems to be by far the larger part of the problem, possibly other ad networks would see an increase but nobody has the advertiser volume required for that other than adsense.
Of course the final outcome of something like that remains to be seen but I'm fairly sure it would be a net positive.
And they could always default it to 'off'.
Google don't want to send you to made-for-adsense sites. These account for a tiny portion of their income while degrading both their search results & their advertising offering. Google' two primary concerns.
This is actually an amazingly good idea!
It should be possible to build such a product on top of Google search. And you have a competitive advantage against Google: they will never ban sites that use AdSense, it would kill their $10B market. So you are safe.
It also leaves you with the subtle problem of where you're going to find a way to monetize, adsense would be 'out'.
edit: another way google could fix this is by no longer counting visitors that they send to sites when those visitors click on adsense ads.
In other words your adsense income can not come from selling google traffic back to google.
That would likely cure 90% of the problem, since these sites have 0 autonomous traffic.
You could put your own ads on your search results. The point is that people would prefer to search from your site, because your results would be even better (more relevant) than Google's.
People wouldn't go to your site because they can't stand ads, but because they want to find links that are not filled with ads.
-ads-from:google.com
(I'm not holding my breath, though.)I might even switch :)
- lists prices online - is just brochureware - has online ordering - displays their full catalogue - etc
Say I'm trying to get an idea of cost for tapware, I have to browse through x plumbing sites that are just brochureware, or have an only catalogue without pricing, etc.
Similarly for travel, checkboxes for "official site", review site, reseller, etc.
And another PITA is product review pages with SFA reviews.
The simple cure for MFA sites would be to simply ban those pages that use google adsense from search engine results pages.
10 minute fix. Tops. But it will also seriously impact googles revenues and that is why it isn't going to happen.
A really good argument against having too many of these services in the hands of the same company.
The bigger problem, and one that is much harder to fix is that by using the structure of the web to measure page popularity google has put a premium on manipulating the structure of the web for profit.
The damage that has done is a lot bigger than MFA sites, those only affect search engine results.
It is a logical consequence of the ranking method used by a search engine that the damage is limited to that which is being measured.
Altavista led to keyword spam which was limited to the pages of the sites owned by those trying to gain as much traffic as possible from it, Google has led to link spam for exactly the same reason.