Does it, though? Looking at HN usernames, some are clearly names (mine, yours), and many are probably not (patio11, JupeterMoon, hackuser, on__3, to use some from the comments of a neighboring thread). I don't think this detracts at all from the professionalism of the discourse here, nor from the perception thereof.
Similarly, I wouldn't weigh the professionalism of a hypothetical StackExchange user differently if their usernames were 'SparkleMermaid', 'ArmadilloRocketeer', or 'Iheartpython' -- I notice the content of their writing before I notice their name. Heck, the sandwich-themed name of your company shouldn't make one pre-judge the communities you've built, or the perception the work you've done to build them.
Am I that much in the minority that I don't care if your username is your initials + favorite 3 digit number, your real name, or a reference to your favorite Star Trek episide? Is this because I grew up in a time when handles were either assigned-by-name or completely made-up, depending on what system you had joined? Maybe it's the influence of having been a lurker on Slashdot and HN, where clever nicknames were commonplace, yet one's choice of nickname nearly never was the basis for judging value of contributions.
This kind of policy goes a long way towards the perception of professionalism at any web site. You're probably not going to take a person named "Spazmo Jones" as seriously as you would "Amy Wong". It's a sort of broken window theory.
(And yes, all of the examples above are pen names people actually tried to sign up with!)