I'm not sure I buy that. In the mid '80s my dad's secretary had a graduate degree in marine biology, and the attitude was "Yes, she has a graduate degree and she's working as a secretary. But what do you expect? Marine Biology."
The past wasn't as comfortable as people make it out to be.
I'm curious when this started. I graduated from undergrad in Dec. '99. At no point was I told the above. My parents had always pushed for MD/lawyer/engineer with business as a fallback. Keep in mind they were none of those things, and as a family we understood hardship. Maybe that is part of the equation?
When I originally started pre-med the potential salary at the time certainly drove my choice. I found programming as a side elective and switched majors the next semester. Even though I love technology and programming if the salaries didn't match up it would have remained a hobby and not something I majored in.
If everyone has a bachelor's degree, how is everyone going to command a premium income?
As I see it the problem is that it is actually correct at the present time. And despite the vast bulk of private schools claiming to be charitable organizations they act like rapacious capitalists. That being the case we can look at the equilibrium for firms in their positions, which is to capture virtually all of the surplus. That is exactly what they are in the process of doing.
There's probably several different governmental solutions possible, and by all means if you are interested in this issue you should pursue them. But if you want to do something on a personal level, consider forgoing the use of a degree as a proxy in hiring. Just look for whatever ultimate skills and attributes you are interested in directly. This will have a cost to you, the signal is not totally empty, but if adopted on a widespread basis it will have the salutary effect of making colleges live and die on their direct contribution rather than resting on their credentialist laurels.
Then it becomes a starting point, not an end point. Most businesses, when faced with a deluge of BA's, will start to look for people with master degrees. Same thing if they have a highly sought after position and get a deluge of people with masters, then they look for PhD candidates.
This becomes an issue when you have a BA in a field where a majority of people have master degrees. I had several roommates who were engineering and CS graduates. At the time, the economy was shit (early 2000's) and they went back for their masters. Most said it was because when the economy finally bounced back, they would have a leg up on the people they were competing with.
The only problem they found was as the economy recovered, they had more opportunities with a masters degree, but many were hired at the salary level of an entry level engineer.
Is it too harsh to say that this sounds a lot like people not taking responsibility for their own financial mistake?
[1] https://studentaid.ed.gov/sa/sites/default/files/federal-loa...
When there’s a society-wide systemic “failure to take responsibility”, it becomes everyone’s problem, and trying to blame individuals accomplishes nothing except to make whoever is doing the blaming feel smug.
When I went to college (2001-2005) the thought process was "borrow as much as you can, you'll get a good job straight out of college and no one can repo your college degree". I had the head of the financial aid department tell me that borrowing the max every year was fine and dandy and I should keep doing it because my degree wasn't like a car that could be repossessed. So I graduated $38K in debt and spent maybe half of that on actual school with the rest going towards stupid shit that 20 year olds spend too much money on.