News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Trans-Pacific Partnership Trade Deal Is Reached by tptacek on Monday October 05, 2015 @11:44AM (#10332550)
This comic is godawful, and it's embarrassing that it keeps coming up on HN.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9982411

Re:Trans-Pacific Partnership Trade Deal Is Reached by Camillo on Monday October 05, 2015 @01:22PM (#10333282)
You can look at it this way. When the WTO agreement was passed, opponents worried that it would lead to a massive transfer of manufacturing jobs to China, which could undercut the US with lower wages, laxer safety and environmental protection standard, etc. Supporters claimed that it would benefit the average American, not just the wealthy, and that the spread of a market economy would bring democracy to China, which would then pass labor and environmental protection laws similar to our own.

What actually happened is that the WTO led to a massive transfer of manufacturing jobs to China, inequality in the US has increased, China has shown no interest in democracy, the working class there still enjoys low wages and poor working conditions, and they are now the largest polluter in the world.

On top of that, the US as a whole has been weakened, and the fact that we have thrown away any chance of conditioning access to markets on the implementation of air pollution regulations looks ever more regrettable given global warming.

I think it is reasonable to look at that and adjust your priors to trust TPP opponents more and TPP proponents less, even in the absence of any TPP-specific information.

Re:Trans-Pacific Partnership Trade Deal Is Reached by seiji on Monday October 05, 2015 @12:21PM (#10332858)
Well, nobody knows the TPP yet. It's not public. The parts that have leaked are pretty bad. The comic mostly argues against a common hybrid republican/libertarian economic branding of "free trade." Free Trade branding ended up being a disguise for reducing labor costs by moving interchangeable capital to places where people work for (and live off of) $1/day instead of $800/day, but people never get the same freedom of movement rights as corporate capital. So, companies reduce costs, but people can't move to cheaper (or even better) places to improve their own costs.

As for arguing the comic is godawful, maybe de-escalate your rage meter for a while? It's just an informative comic posted to an online text forum run by a multi-billion dollar funding organization. It's all kinda meaningless overall.

Re:Trans-Pacific Partnership Trade Deal Is Reached by tptacek on Monday October 05, 2015 @12:47PM (#10333034)
It's the opposite of an informative comic. It is a comic designed to deceive readers based on an illusory claim of expertise (its author is not an economist, nor is he apparently familiar with the TPP) in order to push an agenda. It is upsetting to see it repeatedly posted to HN.
Re:Trans-Pacific Partnership Trade Deal Is Reached by seiji on Monday October 05, 2015 @12:58PM (#10333112)
As far as I can tell, we aren't licensed and bonded economists either, so there's no ground to take down another not-an-economist (No True Economist?).