[0] - Most of pork barrel spending is not on bridges to no where but on research for diseases, local roads, police officers, VA benefits, emergency response to hurricane Sandy etc...
"The Act was passed on the last day before Congress adjourned for the 2006 elections. According to Sen. Frank Lautenberg (D-N.J.), no one on the Senate-House Conference Committee had seen the final language of the bill before it was passed.[4][5] The Economist has written that these provisions were "hastily tacked onto the end of unrelated legislation"."
Edit to add: I agree that the ability to amend bills shouldn't be removed entirely, but it certainly needs an overhaul.
Sounds good to me! If I ever run for office (ha!), I'd run on a platform of reducing the number of outstanding laws -- e.g. every new law passed requires two antiquated laws to be rescinded. Plus, as a side benefit, we could massively reduce the amount of quid pro quo pork added via amendments. Consider it the legal version of "My net programming contribution this week was -2000 lines of code." [1]
[1] http://www.folklore.org/StoryView.py?story=Negative_2000_Lin...
I often hear people say things like, "If Republicans and Democrats (or the house and senate) could work together, they'd get a lot more done.", and I think to myself, "Is a 'productive' congress one that passes thousands of pages of legislation?".
The point was: Continuously bolting on new {law, code} tends to monotonically increase a system's complexity. Many people consider unnecessary complexity "bad." I'm one of those people.
Whether the ability to add amendments prolongs or delays the passing of laws, that's a tough one.
Meanwhile, amendments now serve the purpose of attaching valence issues (i.e. hyped up issues that turn voters into idiots) onto any significant piece of legislation. See Congress now -- having trouble deciding whether Planned Parenthood funding is worth shutting down the entire federal government.
But the solutin isn't getting rid of amendatory processes, because those processes aren't the root of any contemporary problem. Amendmory processes have been around since long before the US was even a country.
If your proposal became law, Congress would still do these compromises, they would just pass the provisions on a different bill -- say, "vote for my bill and I'll later vote for your pork project in the next appropriation". All that would change is the difficulty of coordinating it. The fundamental problem is still there.
No amount of process-tweaking is going to make any difference if Americans keep electing stupid assholes to public office. Likewise, even a rather broken set of processes can be mitigated if they're administered by intelligent and reasonable people.
(Now, for my pet idea :)
What I would like to see, in addition to an electorate that doesn't make such terrible decisions, is a requirement that every bill have a falsifiable statement of purpose, along with clear and convincing reasoning why the proposed legislation might achieve that purpose. The purpose would always include some time limit. If the purpose of the bill is not achieved by the time the limit is up, then the bill is automatically repealed. If the courts (or some new institution analogous to the courts) determines the the reasoning is not clear, or the time limit is not reasonable (e.g. a million years to do X) then the bill is also repealed.
But even that's going to break down, if administered by idiots.
Consider the erosion of congressional oversight of military actions over that last 100 years. Do you think we'd have troops in combat all over the globe right now if Congress had to vote on the actions taking place? What congressman would vote to put Americans in danger to "train" the Nigerian army?
"After dogged, diverse grassroots pressure delivered major blows to Fast Track, proponents used procedural gimmicks to pass Fast Track through Congress by a one-vote margin ... Fast Track has only been used 16 times in the history of our nation, often to enact the most controversial of "trade" pacts, such as NAFTA and the establishment of the WTO. Meanwhile, hundreds of less controversial U.S. trade agreements have been implemented without resort to Fast Track, showing that the extraordinary procedure is not needed to approve trade agreements."
All fast-track really does is put a timeline to an up-or-down vote for the final treaty. People calling it "undemocratic" are really saying "it's too democratic".
The treaty power of the Constitution is quite clear requiring a supermajority of the Senate to ratify any negotiated treaty.
[The President] shall have Power, by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, to make Treaties, provided two thirds of the Senators present concur...
Fast track is inherently undemocratic as it is negotiated in secret ("no advise and consent") and most likely unconstitutional, but conventional wisdom says it is death for any politician in the US to stand in the way of legislation that "creates jobs" or "protects children".
But reading TPA, it carefully skirts this line. The most questionable part is the no amendments part.
The constitution says:
"All Bills for raising Revenue shall originate in the House of Representatives; but the Senate may propose or concur with Amendments as on other Bills. "
Note the "as on other bills" part, clearly implying they must be able to propose amendments on other bills, and not just bills for raising revenue.
As you can probably tell, I did some quick Google research, and the constitutionality of TPA doesn't see to be a particularly contentious issue, despite being discussed frequently. Got a better source than any of mine? (I can only assume you do.)
It's definitely the case that congress can delegate implied powers to agencies, but generally not explicitly authorized powers that were granted to congress. Here, my one concern is the no amendments part, and nothing else. That is because the constitution prescribes something. and that can't be changed by bill, only by constitutional amendment.
The rest of the delegation, it depends on what exactly is delegated.
See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nondelegation_doctrine in general, which cites a lot of the relevant cases.
Note for example, the infamous line item veto case, etc.
Also note: "Only rarely has the Supreme Court invalidated laws as violations of the nondelegation doctrine"
That is likely true in this case as well.
[1] http://www.libertylawsite.org/2015/05/29/fast-track-for-the-...
[2]Field v. Clark, 143 U.S. 649 (1892)
Agreed. However my point was: they can only do that to the degree that these procedures do not violate explicitly promulgated constitutional requirements.
Ie they cannot decide to give a senator two votes, or declare that votes are decided by something other than yeas and nays, etc. This is because the constitution says that is what is supposed to happen, and you can't override those requirements.
The no amendments appears to possibly run afoul of that, if what i quoted from the constitution is read the way i read it :)
The Constitution gives Congress explicit powers to set its own rules regarding procedure. Among these constitutionally allowed rules are "let's decide not to debate a particular bill the President gives to us". They still get to vote and all the other things the Constitution states; all that has changed is the procedure by which the bill is presented to a vote.
Please read exactly what i quoted, which literally includes a quote from the constitution, instead of building a completely different strawman and tearing it down.
You may find this article helpful or simply search for "Nondelegation doctrine" for more detailed analysis: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nondelegation_doctrine The TPP far exceeds the setting of tariff rates and negotiation of agricultural imports and in fact borders in several areas on setting legislative policy imperially.
For those readers interested in what "fast-track" authority means from Congress' perspective [pdf] https://fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/R43491.pdf is an excellent resource.
In this situation, a Congress being paid off by big companies voted to let a number of those companies, the executive branch, and foreign countries come up with all the terms of an agreement that can essentially replace domestic laws. And then they will vote yes or no on it all at once, a situation that previously made things too big to fail (reject). This is quite unlike how our laws are meant to be formed. Further evidence is how elites and powerful companies that often act at odds with the majority here get to read & contribute to terms but majority that will be affected by them don't. They just have to accept whatever terms are dictated by one branch of government, some foreign ones, and private parties with a history of abusing consumers for profit. Sounds more fascist than democratic...
The bigger point was made by a commenter way down the page. The question was, "Does a treaty like this lock us into all kinds of rules from environment to I.P. that prevent future legislation from improving these?" We're currently facing battles against rich firms over copyright, patents (esp software and medicine), environmental abuses, shady practices in agriculture, and so on. Americans and legislators have a chance of dealing with this through our legal process. Can that happen after an elite-controlled treaty makes rules for all this that benefit them and the countries agree to them? Huge risk there that's hard to quantify.
Let's not get into the details of how they could actually see it (sort of), but couldn't get a copy to review with experts, or with their constituents.
If Robert Aderholt doesn't like the TPP, he's perfectly free to vote against it.
Excluding public stakeholders from the development of legislation will not make their issues disappear, it will only force those concerns into alternate vehicles of expression, https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consent_of_the_governed
Look at the devastating impact that NAFTA had had on the nation. That sort of change should require a high threshold to pass.
I don't think straight up-or-down votes are necessarily the best vector for public policy in all cases! I'm not saying that it was unreasonable to oppose fast-track. I'm saying that calling fast-track "undemocratic" is a bogus argument.
As idiotic as it would have been to allow the Congressman from the Arkansas 3rd, home to no major cities unless you consider the headquarters of Walmart a city, to directly alter trade law, Congress could have done that. They retained the authority to filibuster or amend the TPP enabling bill.
Thankfully, several months ago, they voted and agreed not to let that happen.
Congress changes laws all the time. That's their job.
"As idiotic as it would have been to allow the Congressman from the Arkansas 3rd, home to no major cities unless you consider the headquarters of Walmart a city, to directly alter trade law"
Are you seriously arguing that Walmart doesn't have an impact on trade? Or that international trade only affects "major cities"?
I assure you that you are wrong about both of those things.
"Thankfully, several months ago, they voted and agreed not to let that happen."
And tomorrow they might change their minds.
Where does this idea that a law can't ever be changed once it is passed come from?
"The fast track negotiating authority for trade agreements is the authority of the President of the United States to negotiate international agreements that Congress can approve or disapprove but cannot amend or filibuster."
It "was in effect from 1975 to 1994" "and from 2002 to 2007" "Although it expired for new agreements" "it continued to apply to agreements already under negotiation until they were eventually passed into law in 2011." "In June 2015, TPA passed Congress and was signed by the President."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fast_track_%28trade%29