Larry kinda went, "NO IT"S THIS." and there was Camelia.
Honestly, Camelia is just slightly worse than the redesign of The Life Aquatic Flag/Logo. Which itself was funny, as this was from a comedy [1].
[0] http://www.nntp.perl.org/group/perl.perl6.users/2009/01/msg9...
[1] https://www.google.com/search?q=The+Life+Aquatic+with+Steve+...
I was under the impression that Larry was banned from being in involved in the implementation of Perl 6. ;)
I kinda saw that logo and gave up the idea of helping. It was just so horrible as to defy logic.
Still love Perl and I think a butterfly is a great idea - and even this is a good as a start, but it's not a strong enough logo for people to have careers depend upon. Like me. It doesn't even tick all the checkboxes that Larry had. If you made this logo in an intro design class in art school, you'd be ridiculed.
[0] http://www.nntp.perl.org/group/perl.perl6.users/2009/03/msg9...
> As is the idea that aggression is a purely masculine trait
I didn't say it was a purely masculine trait, but to ignore the clear association between masculinity and aggression in many cultures is to ignore reality. There are many social, economic and (possibly) evolutionary reasons why men are often more aggressive than women. Couple this with the relative involvement of women in CS and programming positions, and I don't think it's a stretch to say that aggression in our industry can be seen as overly masculine.
> I also take it as a given that we want to discourage misogyny in our community.
All I want to know is what does the one have to do with the other? What does a butterfly logo have to do with the concept of sexism towards women? That's it. That's my question. I have no idea how to state it more simply.
Someone suggested that "discouraging misogyny" does not necessarily mean femininity, so I asked what "discouraging misogyny" does mean in this context, and you replied "not overtly masculine".
That response does not simply allude to the idea that masculinity is misogyny, it is literally saying that masculinity is misogyny. Hence my reply that the very idea is itself sexist and dangerous. It was my response to your saying masculinity is misogyny, and your interpretation of Larry's original statement about the logo to mean as such. That is not projecting, that is simple reading comprehension.
By being gender neutral and inviting in an industry with is definitively male dominated, and arguably male-centric.
> It was my response to your saying masculinity is misogyny
I did not say masculinity is misogyny, please don't extend your argument to my statements providing and alternate interpretation. My interpretation is this: You can fight misogyny by being open and inviting to all sexes. Being overtly masculine can hamper that. Let's not be overtly masculine.
To be clear, I think the root difference in our points of view is that you seem to have attributed a very specific meaning to one particular statement of his. I think there is not enough context to make a definitive assertion as to his meaning, so out of the possible interpretations I chose one that is more positive.
[0] https://twitter.com/CreativeCopper1/status/65167580812206080...
I might perceive this differently because of my cultural background, but isn't it a bit misandric to claim masculinity as unsensitive?
Tom Cooks
* Something a programming language with wide use would ever adopt, past, present, or future
* ..and is misogynistic in any way
What the hell is that sentence directed at?
Discussion Highlights =====================
From: Larry Wall Date: March 24, 2009 10:25 Subject: Re: Logo considerations
[...] I think there's a tendency to go way too abstract in most of these proposals. I want something with gut appeal on the order of Tux. In particular I want a logo for Perl 6 that is:
In addition, you can extend just about anything by attaching "P6" wings to it. I also take it as a given that we want to discourage misogyny in our community. You of the masculine persuasion should consider it an opportunity to show off your sensitive side. :)Hence, Camelia.
Larry