I would rather have less ad tracking pixels on someone elses websites if possible, but I am genuinely interested in the value that gravatar provides to people who like the service.
But the recommended way is to prefetch the avatars directly from your server and offer them on your own cdn.
As for the value it provides, well for one thing I pretty much never have to upload my avatar to websites anymore - it's an avatar attached to my email addresses instead and that's very nice. Of course I'd prefer a proper identity protocol but nobody's working on one. If you want to, be my guest...
I would rather external actors (say gravatar does nothing wrong) not be able to identify which email address I use on a site they do not own, and not be able to track my user signups by something that might be public information, which generally a site does not advertise.
It just feels wrong.