Re:The Reign of Recycling
by specialist on Sunday October 04, 2015 @10:42PM
(#10329704)
Pigovian tax?
Tierney writes:
It would be much simpler and more effective to impose the equivalent of a carbon tax on garbage, as Thomas C. Kinnaman has proposed
I already pay to have someone haul away my garbage, yard waste, recycling.
How is what you, Tierney, and Kinnaman propose different?
[Kinnaman's paper is paywalled.]
In New York City, it is against the law not to recycle. Paying for garbage removal (via taxes, or preferably, a per bag fee), but not for (realistically) recyclable trash removal, would be a good start.
It seems obvious to me that the right answer to waste is to apply a Pigovian tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pigovian_tax , which is what Tierney is suggesting with the $15 tax per ton of landfill waste. Then, materials that can be profitably separated (currently, paper, aluminum, and cardboard) would be exempted from the fee if you separate them.
The great problem I have with current recycling is that it is not based on any realistic theory of monetizing externalities.