Re:Free Lossless Image Format
by colanderman on Friday October 02, 2015 @12:34PM
(#10319552)
A compressed image which does not reconstitute to the original image is by definition lossy. You can't scale a PNG down by 25% and call that "lossless compression".
Though I'll gladly take your logic and call the first 1/64th of a progressive JPEG lossess (which it is, since at that point you only have the DC offsets of basic blocks, which undergo no lossy compression).
Re:Free Lossless Image Format
by jonsneyers on Friday October 02, 2015 @06:07PM
(#10321640)
I think JPEG's color transform is lossy, so even those basic blocks are somewhat lossy. A better approximation of the entire 8x8 block than the exact pixel at the top-left position of the block, which is what FLIF and PNG with Adam7 interlacing do, but still lossy. If you would take an image, magnify it by a factor of 8 in both directions so each pixel gets blown up to an 8x8 block, then convert it to JPEG, there is still some information lost.
It'd be more accurate to compare it to a pre-generated resizing of the original image (at the same effective resolution as the "half downloaded" FLIF).