Re:Mass incarceration: A new theory for why so many American...
by tptacek on Friday October 02, 2015 @05:20PM
(#10321413)
Rayiner's comment seems like a strong rebuttal to this:
Re:Mass incarceration: A new theory for why so many American...
by Nursie on Friday October 02, 2015 @06:00PM
(#10321612)
It doesn't have a strong rebuttal, because it doesn't actually have any exact figures.
It has trends which suggest it's of little relevance, sure, but nothing particularly concrete. For all we know the homicide rate in the mid 80s (for example) may have dropped to a historic low without the WoD.
Re:Mass incarceration: A new theory for why so many American...
by tptacek on Friday October 02, 2015 @06:31PM
(#10321729)
Doesn't that require you to argue that transitioning from "no war on drugs" to "war on drugs" back to "no war on drugs" would reduce the murder rate, lower than it was before the war on drugs?
If not, can you help me understand why?
I disagree. I think it's unsatisfying because it naively minimises the wider effects of the WoD.
I'm not American so I don't really have a vested interest in your prison population and why it's there, I only really know that compared to your population size it's huge.
I am quite pedantic though, and it looked to me like firstly it wasn't complete in its reasoning and secondly like 300K people out of 1.7M is still a very significant amount.