Re:Free Lossless Image Format
by ekianjo on Friday October 02, 2015 @10:23AM
(#10318715)
Jon Sneyers is a known advocate of Free Software, I am actually glad he acts on his beliefs.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Based on how he's acted in the past, I think even Stallman would've advocated something like the MIT or BSD license for something like this -- having a patent-unencumbered alternative to formats like JPEG 2000 being used seems to be more important to a lot of Free Software people. In other words, the advantage of having widely-used file formats that are accessible to free software programs are considered greater than the benefits of having software become libre in order to use GPL'd file format libraries. Stallman defended the use of a non-copyleft license for Ogg/Vorbis on those grounds:
> even Stallman would've advocated something like the MIT or BSD license for something like this
Almost, Stallman (well, the FSF) advocates Apache 2:
Some libraries implement free standards that are competing against restricted
standards, such as Ogg Vorbis (which competes against MP3 audio) and WebM
(which competes against MPEG-4 video). For these projects, widespread use of
the code is vital for advancing the cause of free software, and does more
good than a copyleft on the project's code would do.
In these special situations, we recommend the Apache License 2.0.
Source: https://www.gnu.org/licenses/license-recommendations.html