In short, it's the _spiral_ that dictates the pattern, not how we label the points on the spiral.
As for what the pattern "means", well, it's hard to say and it might just our mind trying to make order where there is none. On the other hand, there are number theoretical conjectures that would account for certain aspects of the pattern, showing that it's more than just a psychological phenomenon.
Are you sure you're not trolling? I guess a troll wouldn't answer.
In the example given in the book, Ulam creates rows of 10, so the base is significant to how the diagonals are found.
Yes I understand the basis of number theory is to abstract away such things as the base. But the number of times I've read about number theorists and how they found their way to some pattern or truth that seems to depend on base 10 seems weird.
So it is with this Ulam example: why is this a valid way to investigate the problem? It only seems valid in base 10 to me.
I don't even know what "rows of 10" means in the context of the Ulam spiral.
I wish I could find the example of Erdos work where I felt the same way... but the pile of his work is too immense.
Still, though, my karma hasn't taken enough of a beating: viewing a result set in binary and comparing it to automata output still seems a shortcut to understanding. That's an idea that is unpopular for sure.
An example of such a property is that a real number in the interval [0,1] is a member of the Cantor set if and only if it has no 1's in its base 3 representation (not a typo, yes, base 3).
For an example of base-10 centrism that I'm talking about (not specifically Erdos, but from the biography "The Man Who Loved Only Numbers" on page 106 there is a discussion of Stan Ulam writing integers in a spiral and finding primes connected by diagonals. What possible meaning does this pattern have outside of base 10?
This is the part of number theory that confuses me: why should such pattern finding matter, outside of base 10?