News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What's Wrong With This Snowflake? by stcredzero on Monday January 04, 2010 @02:41PM (#1031031)
Okay, so the crystals tend to follow a 6-sided geometry. Why are snowflakes symmetrical? Why does one arm have to fall into the exact same configuration as the opposite one? Why not have 6 different arms, all following the same 6-sided geometry? What mechanism communicates between the arms to achieve 6-sided symmetry?
Re:What's Wrong With This Snowflake? by jerf on Monday January 04, 2010 @03:34PM (#1031164)
Well, they don't have to: http://www.its.caltech.edu/~atomic/snowcrystals/class/class....

Given that different conditions produce different crystals (see for instance the description for the "capped columns"), my best guess is simply that each of the 6 sides experienced all-but-identical growth conditions, and thus the correct question is rather why would they be different?

Someone else mentioned 12- and 3-siders, and trying to Google up those images is how I got to that site in the first place. See: http://www.its.caltech.edu/~atomic/snowcrystals/unusual/unus... (Note you have to "-paper" in the Google search, or you'll just be hammered with instructions for paper snowflakes of varying degrees of scientific inauthenticity.)

Edit: Ah, the site addresses that: http://www.its.caltech.edu/~atomic/snowcrystals/faqs/faqs.ht...

"While [a snowflake] grows, the crystal is blown to and fro inside the clouds, so the temperature it sees changes randomly with time. But the crystal growth depends strongly on temperature (as is seen in the morphology diagram). Thus the six arms of the snow crystal each change their growth with time. And because all six arms see the same conditions at the same times, they all grow about the same way. The end result is a complex, branched structure that is also six-fold symmetric. And note also that since snow crystals all follow slightly different paths through the clouds, individual crystals all tend to look different."

And see also the next question, "What synchronizes the growth of the six arms?". I'm hitting the limit of what I feel comfortable just copying and pasting into HN.

Re:What's Wrong With This Snowflake? by gjm11 on Monday January 04, 2010 @03:44PM (#1031187)
Well, it turns out if you look closely that usually the arms aren't exactly the same. Which is rather a clue: the coordinating mechanism isn't some kind of quantum magic that enables the structure in the centre to determine exactly what the arms are like. Rather, (1) the arms all start out roughly the same because the crystal structure of ice has 6-fold symmetry, and then (2) the way growth happens at any place and any given moment is largely determined by (a) the structure there and (b) the external conditions, which vary as the snowflake is forming because it's being blown around. But because the snowflake is quite small, those external conditions are generally much the same for all six arms; so similar arms + similar conditions for each arm --> similar incremental growth for all arms --> still-similar arms, so the symmetry is preserved as the crystal grows. See, e.g., http://www.ams.org/notices/200504/fea-adam-3.pdf .
Re:What's Wrong With This Snowflake? by JoeAltmaier on Monday January 04, 2010 @02:55PM (#1031074)
I've often wondered about this too. Pseudo-scientific "explanations" of natural phenomenon often ignore the obvious questions. Another interesting question: why do people swallow facile explanations for things with little/no critical dialog?
Re:What's Wrong With This Snowflake? by JoeAltmaier on Monday January 04, 2010 @02:56PM (#1031077)
You're right, frost on a window grows asymmetrically, why not snowflakes?
Re:What's Wrong With This Snowflake? by Confusion on Monday January 04, 2010 @03:40PM (#1031180)
Without knowing the answer, here is my guess: the way a flake grows depends on a number of environmental factors. Although these factors, like temperature, humidity and wind, all vary as the drop/flake falls down, the factors are nearly constant over the size of the flake. Each part of the flake experiences the same environment and as a result all parts grow in the same fashion.

My alternate guess is that snowflakes actually aren't symmetrical, although they display many local 6-way symmetries.

Edit: ah, the answer by jerf verifies that these guesses were reasonable.

Re:What's Wrong With This Snowflake? by horseass on Monday January 04, 2010 @11:21PM (#1031847)
I don't know, but its probably like a cellular automata on a hexagonal 2d plane (like wolfram 'new kind of science' stuff). I wonder why they're flat/ not 3d- I guess something do do with falling and air resistance. I wonder what role initial conditions or randomness while developing play in the wide variety of unique snowflake designs. If randomness while developing has much to do with it, it seems like the 'limbs' of 1 snowflake should develope differently. Doesn't seem like there'd be that many combinations at the initial molecular level to support that many designs.