Edit: data protection would also have a huge effect on the "peeple" app, discussion of which seems to be banned on HN.
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personally_identifiable_inform...
You may never give userdata to anyone else or give anyone else access to userdata.
Embedding tracking scripts from third parties is equally problematic. Google Analytics should be globally forbidden.
Whose side are you on?
However, hilarity has already ensued. The gov here is so incompetent that they couldn't even make an annoucement without having a bunch of gov websites taken down by a manual DDOS attack yesterday [1]. A few thousand people coordinated via social media to repeatedly visit the gov's ICT website which brought it to a standstill. Yet the gov thinks they can manage a single internet gateway to facilitate surveillance and it won't be ruinous.
[1] http://www.bangkokpost.com/news/general/714432/single-gatewa...
How do you know this? They get paid for the data and selling it to the government guarantees that they will be allowed to keep collecting it in the future. It's clearly a mutually beneficial agreement.
Other people having my number on their phone means Google collects that data, too.
Same with Facebook.
I have no choice to opt out, so unless they provide me such a choice, they have to be regulated by law.
On your last point, you want the same people who demand and coerce data from Google and Apple, also be the same people who make the rules for Google and Apple?
Facebook is the #1 vector of US government's indiscriminate spying on everybody's else's citizens. Google comes a close second, but you don't generally give Google as many personal details as you give to Facebook. At least not by your own free will.
And that's really the problem that France has, everyone uses American services so America can basically create a dossier on everyone. No one uses French services other than French citizens, and perhaps a few other souls.