News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Study: Some car models consuming around 50% more fuel tha... by semi-extrinsic on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @05:42PM (#10307563)
So I threw together a histogram [1] of car CO2 emissions as reported by manufacturers for 1200+ model/engine combos. It's not exactly uniformly distributed, to say the least, there is a strong peak at 99 g/km etc. Now that's maybe not conclusive evidence that they are lying, but it's certainly suspicious.

[1] http://asmunder.github.io/2015/09/A-histogram-of-CO2-emissio...

Re:Study: Some car models consuming around 50% more fuel tha... by rnovak on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @06:10PM (#10307766)
I'm not sure what that proves, at least relative to what I'm saying?

IFF the EPA's regulatory test procedure accurately described/expressed normal driving habits, then the only way that numbers would differ between the real world and the reported numbers would be fraud/lying/alteration, like what Volkswagen Group engaged in (let there be no mistake, it WAS fraud/lying, not a case of poor optimization).

BUT the EPA's regulatory test DOES NOT accurately depict normal driving conditions.

In the current case, a manufacturer has to:

     - Realize and Formally accept that the test procedure is inaccurate
     - Optimize for:
         - Simulated driving conditions, aka the Test Procedure
         - Real life driving
To me, it looks like GM just didn't do any of that, and only optimized for the simulated conditions and not real world road conditions.

Depending how far out of wack the test procedure really is could explain the entire data-set.

Re:Study: Some car models consuming around 50% more fuel tha... by semi-extrinsic on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @06:27PM (#10307868)
So the point is that these official numbers should be taken with a generous pinch of salt.

Now, when you talk about GM, remember this is data from Germany, so GM essentially means Opel. Now I believe that before the quite successfull Insignia which launched in 2008, Opel were mainly known for cheap and efficient and small cars like the Corsa and Astra, while now they have a more premium lineup, and "Turbo" versions of several models.

Re:Study: Some car models consuming around 50% more fuel tha... by rnovak on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @10:05PM (#10308788)
Yes exactly, with a pinch of salt. Exactly what I was trying to say.

And yeah, I've driven a Chevy Spark, and that thing was so slow I could get out and walk faster. I could totally see people driving with their foot to the floor in it.