Death penalty aside, the boss that order to kill people should be given a lighter punishment because he didn't execute the evil action directly? I think he should have an heavier sentence instead.
That's quite debatable.
I'm not sure I even believe that the boss who ordered a kill is even guilty of a crime. If his subordinate didn't actually pull a trigger then no crime would be committed. How can one person's crime be a function of another person's actions. It just doesn't compute.
If you take out a murder-for-hire contract on someone else, irrespective of if that contact is carried out, your intent is illegal, immoral, and wrong.
Now our legal system weighs both intent AND consequences. For example someone who hits someone else with their car may get charged with very different crimes depending on if that person lives or dies.
Just to put you in the hot seat for a second, would you yourself want to live in a world where I could take out a contract on your life, and doing so would be entirely legal UNLESS they successfully killed you? Effectively allowing me to take out infinite contracts with complete impunity until you were dead?
Yes because presumably the degenerate who actually pulled the trigger would be punished.
I believe there's only one guilty man in this scenario, and he's the one who pulled the trigger.
Those are two separate actions, both of which are illegal.
The second part is incorrect; soliciting murder (or conspiring with another to commit murder; ordering a hit might be either or both depending on specific details) is a crime whether or not the murder actually occurs.
If the murder actually occurs as a result of the solicitation/conspiracy, they are guilty of another and more serious crime, on top of the ones they were already guilty of. But they are guilty of a crime even without that.
> How can one person's crime be a function of another person's actions. It just doesn't compute.
Because in many cases, law is written and operates on the principal that if you take action intended to cause a result, and that does cause that result (whether or not there is an intermediary whose action is necessary), then you are culpable for the legal consequences of intentionally acting to produce that result, since that's exactly what you've done.
Not in this country. In the Uniform Code of Military Justice (which governs the actions of our armed forces) it is a soldier's explicit responsibility to not follow illegal orders.
And if a subordinate is not qualified or capable of determining if his actions are a crime or not (I'm thinking of a hitman, or mob underling), then that doesn't change whether or not he's guilty of the crime.
You're joking, right? It should be legal to hire a hitman to kill someone? Or convince someone else to burn down my competitor's building? That's madness.
No, at that point it would be the crime of attempted murder.
I disagree with this. It shouldn't matter whether your murder weapon is a baseball bat or a person you've hired, in both cases you're equally guilty. It's similar to the case of a bomber: the fact that they didn't personally perform a violent act, just built a machine, doesn't absolve them of guilt. (For the record, I don't support the death penalty, but I think that murder and hiring a hitman should carry the same penalty).
> making life in prison a far worse punishment than the death penalty
Your second paragraph seems to contradict itself. If life in prison is worse than the death penalty, then the possibility of wrongful convictions should make the death penalty more appealing, since some of those we imprison for life will be innocent.
Did you really just say that? If someone is locked away and their conviction is overturned, we can always let them out. However, we cannot dig them up after we kill them.
I'm actually trying to disagree with the statement that the death penalty is more humane than life in prison. If you assume that's true, one consequence is that we should prefer to execute innocent people rather than imprison them for life. If you think that conclusion is absurd (like I do), then you should reconsider the original statement.
It should be highlighted that this is actually a relatively recent understanding, and still by no means a universal one.
It is cruel and absolutely horrific to keep a human being in isolation. It is against our nature in every way and people literally lose their minds.
This is a fate worse than death.
So what do you do when an inmate is a clear danger to other inmates? When an inmate has clearly shown that he will murder those who are imprisoned with him?
You have two choices. Isolation or death.
There are other reasons for the death "penalty", but I certainly agree that it should never be used as a penalty, but as a measure of last resort.
Or psychiatric treatment.
You want to drug them until they're a vegetable? Ok, I guess that's an option, but I would still put that under "worse than death" category.
There are irregular aspects to this case, but the idea of hitman hirers being immune from the DP is pretty crazy. That's the same as murdering someone with your own hands, both morally and legally.
This is actually not a good argument at all in-favor of the death penalty for this person but rather another great argument for its elimination entirely.
The field of neuroscience based psychiatry and the works of the great minds like Robert Sapolsky must prevail. This has to stop.
So you want to ban abortion? Assisted suicide?
Do I "want" to stop assisted suicide? No.
Do I "want" an end to organised execution of convicted criminals? Yes.
Your move.
1. There are times when doctors, in order to reduce pain in their patients, accelerate their death as part of pain management. This is usually done at the end of long incurable illnesses or injuries from which recovery is unlikely. The consequence of alleviating pain can be death. Whether it is thought of deliberately or not by the caregivers/doctors does not matter. The point is that the event of death is hastened directly by the act of helping the patient.
2. The patient is choosing to end his life. (I hope you don't ask what is to be done with depression/suicidal patients.)
... and lastly, and simply:
3. Many times the assistance may be done by a non-doctor - so the Hippocratic Oath may not apply directly.
It is troubling that there's zero evidence other than the word of a "hitman".
Personally, I don't understand why we have the death penalty in the US. First, the possibility of a wrongful conviction is real. Second, we have prisons that are brutal and allow very few escapes, making life in prison a far worse punishment than the death penalty. Remember that the death penalty for a prisoner these days consists of falling asleep and not waking up. There simply are no valid reasons to impose the death penalty in a country like the US.