Re:Windows 7 Update appears to be compromised?
by cwyers on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @01:07PM
(#10305424)
If someone has managed to compromise Windows Update (which I doubt seriously based on what's presented here), why on Earth would they not bother to come up with text more convincing than the garbage on display here?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Windows 7 Update appears to be compromised?
by markbnj on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @01:09PM
(#10305443)
Yeah I'd say it's more likely someone or something in the update toolchain screwed up.
Re:Windows 7 Update appears to be compromised?
by chengiz on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @01:46PM
(#10305712)
The other option is a deliberate "ethical" hack.
Re:Windows 7 Update appears to be compromised?
by cwyers on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @01:49PM
(#10305737)
Wouldn't that also call for putting in text that at least makes it clear it's an ethical hack? The only explanation for that garbage is either lorem ipsit filler text (something never meant to get out) or the theory buffoon had about it being a hash collision.
Re:Windows 7 Update appears to be compromised?
by drzaiusapelord on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @02:52PM
(#10306208)
Because its not a hack most likely, its just MS screwing up. As someone who has managed/been tortured by WSUS for years, nothing surprises me about how MS handles its update infrastructure. WU is something of a pig and errors come up now and again, both on the client and server-side. In 24 hours this will be forgotten and yet another example of web hysteria.
Considering MS's typical QA with updates, this shouldn't be terribly surprising. I'm going to guess that this was a test patch that got loose. Big companies aren't fault immune, if anything they are fault prone.
Re:Windows 7 Update appears to be compromised?
by cwyers on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @03:01PM
(#10306265)
> Because its not a hack most likely, its just MS screwing up.
That was my point, yeah.
Re:Windows 7 Update appears to be compromised?
by buffoon on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @01:10PM
(#10305448)
That might have been the only text that allowed the updated to be signed.
Re:Windows 7 Update appears to be compromised?
by dpark on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @01:25PM
(#10305568)
That's an interesting theory, but seems unlikely given that the TLDs are all real. Also that would imply a successful hash collision attack which seems exceedingly unlikely. And if true, why not mutate some random bytes in the payload to get the collision rather than the update text (which also may not actually even be stored as part of the signed update).
Re:Windows 7 Update appears to be compromised?
by anonymfus on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @02:12PM
(#10305906)
May be their attack is so specific that they could only use Microsoft signed files in update payload, so they send old vulnerable versions.
Re:Windows 7 Update appears to be compromised?
by dpark on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @02:17PM
(#10305947)
That would be an amazing exploit. I doubt it's the case, and I hope it's not, but it would be pretty amazing.
Re:Windows 7 Update appears to be compromised?
by AustinDizzy on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @03:48PM
(#10306610)
Well, two years ago I tried to report a few fairly critical security vulnerabilities on update.windows.com and they responded saying it wasn't an issue. I'd consider denial of service, buffer overflow, possible remote code execution (didn't test because I didn't want to make MSFT mad), and sensitive configuration information enumeration critical vulnerabilities. Especially on update.microsoft.com, which distributes Windows updates. But apparently they don't. So who knows.
I'm not saying the OP's link is a result of these vulns being exploited, but them being exploited is always a possibility in the future if it hasn't already happened or been fixed.