Re:Paris city centre goes car-free for a day
by tomjen3 on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @01:14PM
(#10305483)
Incentives matter, but the effect is never what you want.
Put more bicycle lanes up and people will buy mopeds (which polutes like crazy), or take jobs elsewhere, or something else crazy.
A good example is probably Australia where they made helmets mandatory for adults on bicycles. So many more people choose to take their car that the number of saved lives were offset by the amount of exercise lost.
Re:Paris city centre goes car-free for a day
by jrock08 on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @09:21PM
(#10308647)
So, helmet laws are actually a terrible example of "effects aren't what you want", at least, it's a terrible example if the implication is that we are getting an effect that we don't expect. Now, it's possible that the legislators didn't understand this, but cycling advocates were and are well aware that helmet laws cause reduced bicycle use. Here's an article with sources which claims to be from 2006, the website copyright notice is 2013, so at the very least, it's from right around when Australia implemented it's helmet law. http://bicycleaustin.info/laws/helmet-laws-bad.html
Re:Paris city centre goes car-free for a day
by rfrey on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @02:03PM
(#10305846)
A sizeable fraction of people who were biking regularly chose to switch to cars rather than wear a helmet?
That's extraordinary, I'm not saying it didn't happen but it astonishes me.
Re:Paris city centre goes car-free for a day
by jrock08 on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @02:18PM
(#10305959)
Cycling in Australia dropped by about 2% between 2011 and 2013. [1] The biggest issue with helmet laws though is that they significantly neuter bike share programs because people don't want to cary a helmet or use a shared helmet.
[1] page 26 http://www.cycle-helmets.com/cps-2013.pdf
And besides, it's not like Paris doesn't have a precedent of the state forcefully changing the physical landscape of the city, although it may not be too popular with some: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haussmann%27s_renovation_of_Pa...