From an ethics point of view, the intent makes gerrymandering worse than unintentional misrepresentation. If you are not moved by ethical considerations, there is still the purely practical matter that the intent makes it much harder to fix.
Because typically people are bad at public speaking, rhetoric, bargaining, and other means of advocating their interests.
Also, remember we are comparing against the current Congress, which only represents the wealthiest among us. Pretty low bar.
State issues are likewise at the state level. There is no reason to make sure two counties are represented, since they won't get separate laws/taxes.
All that matters is that the people being affected by the laws are equally represented. That cannot happen with districting.
- The people who voted for the loser will not be represented (one of the reasons minorities are underrepresented).
- The need of local representation is illusory. Make a list of all the political issues you care about. How many of them are local?
- The effect of a bi-cameral legislature means that in the Senate, voters in Wyoming have over 60x the voting power of voters in California.
- Voting itself is irrational under a cost/benefit analysis. So by definition, the least rational citizens are picking candidates.
- Name recognition is huge for elections, meaning money will always effect elections.
- Candidates suffer self-selection bias (as well as others). To run, you need to be good at public speaking (fear of public speaking is one of the most common fear in America), look a certain way (no tattoos or piercings allowed), and have a lust for power.
Representation is a math problem. The only solution is random sampling. Replace Congress with 1 house made up of 1,000 randomly sampled citizens and we will have true representation.