Re:Temporary Visas, Meant to Import Talent, Help Ship Jobs A...
by Terr_ on Tuesday September 29, 2015 @10:50PM
(#10301415)
Now you aren't actually talking about workers at all, it's just a retread of "Why is America currently in a wealthier position than India?"
Re:Temporary Visas, Meant to Import Talent, Help Ship Jobs A...
by aianus on Tuesday September 29, 2015 @11:12PM
(#10301498)
More like, why is it morally correct that America should interfere in the free market to maintain its lead over poor foreigners?
Re:Temporary Visas, Meant to Import Talent, Help Ship Jobs A...
by Terr_ on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @01:16PM
(#10305493)
So you also believe that the Indian government is acting immorally when they enact environmental laws? Preventing foreign capital from setting up toxin-dumping industries is also "interfering in the free market" too, you know.
"The free market" is neither (A) a natural state between different nations with different legal codes nor (B) intrinsically moral.
Re:Temporary Visas, Meant to Import Talent, Help Ship Jobs A...
by grinnbearit on Thursday October 01, 2015 @01:16AM
(#10309361)
I believe aianus used "free market" here to mean free access to labour.
I'm more interested in your views on "to maintain its lead over poor foreigners"
Of course they are, because the standard of living is much higher in America. If you prefer, I can rephrase the question as "Why should Americans enjoy a higher standard of living than Indians doing the same work?"