News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scientists say dolphins should be treated as 'non-human p... by jacquesm on Sunday January 03, 2010 @09:37PM (#1029602)
No, you should leave that to the Dolphin police.

To force human norms and laws on Dolphins would be to anthropomorphize (sp?) and that is exactly what the article warns against.

If you start of from the assumption they are non-human persons then you'll have to admit to their right to self govern their society.

Re:Scientists say dolphins should be treated as 'non-human p... by elblanco on Sunday January 03, 2010 @10:33PM (#1029686)
What about when dolphins violate human laws? Like breaking undersea cables or eating fish hauls still in net, or attacking a human or some other such violation?

This would seem to be most closely analogous to an international border violation.

Re:Scientists say dolphins should be treated as 'non-human p... by jacquesm on Sunday January 03, 2010 @10:36PM (#1029690)
No, you are still trying to treat Dolphins as human persons.

Dolphins could not violate human law since they are not human.

International implies nations, Dolphins probably would not recognize nations.

For an encore, with a wink to Douglas Adams, they might not even recognize humans as particularly intelligent.

Re:Scientists say dolphins should be treated as 'non-human p... by elblanco on Sunday January 03, 2010 @10:50PM (#1029720)
Of course we both know that mice are in charge. :)

I think though, what this shows is that there is the potential for a very interesting and lively debate as to how far something like "non-human person" extends. If we don't hold them liable to any kind of responsibility for particular extensions of rights beyond what we'd show any other animal, then are we not just treating them like another animal -- and thus the new classification as a "non-human person" is simply superfluous?

Re:Scientists say dolphins should be treated as 'non-human p... by jacquesm on Sunday January 03, 2010 @11:09PM (#1029744)
I think your right about that (besides the mice being in charge, which we take as given).

The funny thing here is that this is all fine and good as long as we're dealing with inferior intellects, wait what happens if a superior intelligence should come across us and decides to capture and domesticate us and treat us like food.

I'm pretty sure we'd be arguing for equal rights for animals :)

I really don't remember the title of the story, I think it was a short story in an anthology, it read as a 'care and feeding of your khod' or something like that.

The basic idea was that the story was told from the viewpoint of an alien species that kept the obviously non-intelligent khod as a food stock. Lots of rules were laid down about how you should treat your khod if you wanted to get the most mileage out of them.

Particular care should be taken when slaughtering the khod, never do this in front of other khod that you do not intend to slaughter right away.

Only at the end of the story you realize the khod are captive humans.