Re:Shell stops Arctic activity after 'disappointing' tests
by DennisP on Tuesday September 29, 2015 @05:49AM
(#10295318)
If oil is cheaper on average, you need a higher price on carbon to have the same effect. If you manage to get that higher price, the end result is the same as if your cost of production didn't drop in the first place. So why invest in dropping the cost of production?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Shell stops Arctic activity after 'disappointing' tests
by eru on Tuesday September 29, 2015 @07:28AM
(#10295576)
You are mixing up different actors.
At a given tax, the consumer and producer want the lowest production cost.
At fixed price to the consumer, the government wants the lowest production cost, so that the tax can be higher.
Re:Shell stops Arctic activity after 'disappointing' tests
by DennisP on Tuesday September 29, 2015 @08:33AM
(#10295770)
That's assuming the government's goal is to raise revenue. A lot of carbon tax proposals are revenue neutral, with the goal of achieving specific carbon reductions.
Fossil fuel producers may still compete with each other on cost but we shouldn't fool ourselves into thinking they're somehow benefiting society by doing that.