News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Backup Solution? by trjordan on Sunday January 03, 2010 @08:09PM (#1029461)
FWIW, Time Machine can actually be set up to do remote backups. You can even (p)re-configure the disk image if you want to limit the size, in case you don't want to partition your disk. I'll grant that it's a bit of a pain over the 3-click built-in solution, but it's what I'm using these days.

Enabling network backups: http://rajeev.name/blog/2007/11/03/time-machine-with-smb-and...

Limiting backup sizes: http://www.macosxhints.com/article.php?story=200711080201215...

Re:A Backup Solution? by telemachos on Sunday January 03, 2010 @07:28PM (#1029394)
I just bought a TimeMachine here since my whole house is now Mac and it finally seemed worth it. The initial set-up was a bit hairy: my wife's machine got caught in some sort of bad loop and every time we tried to restart her initial backup, it grew. First it was going to be 45 GB. When that failed and died, the next try was 90GB. We killed that, messed with a few things, tried again, and sure enough it was now going to be 135. Ugly.

Having said that, after wiping the TimeMachine and starting from scratch, everything has been perfect. And obviously all the backups after the initial one are very small and quite fast. So I suppose I would give it a B-.

Re:A Backup Solution? by pclark on Sunday January 03, 2010 @07:15PM (#1029376)
Re:A Backup Solution? by telemachos on Sunday January 03, 2010 @07:27PM (#1029392)
The blog post specifically mentions tarsnap in a list of applications that he then dismisses (they don't "just work").

You might disagree, but if you do, please say why.

Re:A Backup Solution? by eli on Sunday January 03, 2010 @08:40PM (#1029504)
I'd probably agree that it doesn't "just work" (in the sense that e.g. dropbox just works), but if you're reasonably comfortable with a command line and have used tar before, it's pretty straightforward.
Re:A Backup Solution? by jhancock on Sunday January 03, 2010 @10:20PM (#1029667)
The article does not support the author's 'just works' perspective. Its not much of an article at all but simply lists a few product he's tried on various platforms.

For me, I expect a certain amount of setup in any secure and fairly robust backup solution. tarsnap has very little setup for a person that loves the command line.

Re:A Backup Solution? by weaksauce on Sunday January 03, 2010 @07:56PM (#1029448)
I don't get his definition of "Just work" though. First he says that For Macs, there’s Time Machine, BackBlaze, Mozy, and Carbonite. But none of them seem to just work.

Time machine has got to be the easiest backup software I have used. That is the definition of just work in my book. Tarsnap looks cool but it is command line only so I can see why he dismissed it for a "just work" solution.

Edit: OK I went back and read his old article where he defines just work and Time machine does not "Just work" according to his definition.

Re:A Backup Solution? by drewcrawford on Sunday January 03, 2010 @07:52PM (#1029441)
The problem with these sorts of services is that they require finicky clientside software.

The problem with real "storage" services (S3, Rackspace, etc.) is that they're ridiculously expensive--on the order of "buy a new backup drive every few months" expensive. Plus there's no way to ship drives to them or have them ship drives to you in an emergency.

I'd love to colocate a Backblaze pod in a datacenter and just rsync a few TB up to it. That way I can handle my own xattrs, my own bare metal, and not worry about finicky client software. Problem: $8k or so is way outside my backup budget...

Yeah, I know I could just colocate a $500 NAS, but it seems to wasteful to have so much CPU, power, etc., just for one backup.

If only we could round up a few hundred HNers to split a Backblaze pod...

Re:A Backup Solution? by weaksauce on Sunday January 03, 2010 @08:18PM (#1029475)
WOW... that is impressive. 67TB in a 4U. They put a lot of thought into those servers.

http://blog.backblaze.com/2009/09/01/petabytes-on-a-budget-h...

Edit: Impressive service and great price point. It looks like the only thing that I would want to have as well is geographic redundancy too.

Re:A Backup Solution? by jcapote on Sunday January 03, 2010 @09:54PM (#1029635)
FYI, you can mail drives to S3: http://aws.amazon.com/importexport/
Re:A Backup Solution? by drewcrawford on Sunday January 03, 2010 @10:02PM (#1029646)
Device Handling $80.00 per storage device handled.

Data Loading Time $2.49 per data-loading-hour. Partial data-loading-hours are billed as full hours.

Yes, on the order of cost-of-drive.

Re:A Backup Solution? by jhancock on Sunday January 03, 2010 @10:22PM (#1029668)
For my servers (linux), I use tarsnap. For my workstations (OS X) I use SuperDuper.app to image my hard drive.
Re:A Backup Solution? by thaumaturgy on Sunday January 03, 2010 @07:21PM (#1029384)
We've spent many hours evaluating different backup services -- we're specifically looking for one with a partner program that's appropriate for our business.

The good news is, most services now (claim to) offer encryption as part of their basic package.

For Mac users, Carbonite does seem to be the best service available. For Windows users, I'd recommend SpiderOak, who are cheaper in most cases than other services, and they seem to offer a reasonably good client program.

For potential resellers, in our opinion there just isn't a good one available yet. We hadn't found CrashPlan though, and so far it looks promising.

Re:A Backup Solution? by cperciva on Sunday January 03, 2010 @08:05PM (#1029453)
The good news is, most services now (claim to) offer encryption as part of their basic package.

Yet they still make n00b mistakes like "we recommend that you use the built-in encryption key (which everybody who downloads the client software has access to)". And when they don't announce their mistakes publicly, they still don't provide enough technical details (e.g., cipher block mode) to confirm that they're not making dumb mistakes behind the scenes. (It doesn't help when people refuse to make source code available, of course.)

Re:A Backup Solution? by sreitshamer on Sunday January 03, 2010 @07:33PM (#1029405)
The problem IMHO is that the encryption is just that -- a "claim". You can't access your data on their servers, so you can't verify it. You can use your own password, but there's no way to verify it's being used. Backblaze's blog http://tr.im/BPfR for instance says that "IT" has access to my data without knowing my password.
Re:A Backup Solution? by thaumaturgy on Sunday January 03, 2010 @07:48PM (#1029433)
One of the advantages (and disadvantages) to CrashPlan, for service providers, is that it allows you to run their server software on your own infrastructure.

But yes, I agree with you otherwise. I'd much rather trust cperciva with data, but unfortunately his system lacks some critical features for our uses.

Re:A Backup Solution? by cperciva on Sunday January 03, 2010 @10:54PM (#1029726)
I'd much rather trust cperciva with data, but unfortunately his system lacks some critical features for our uses.

If you haven't already done so, please send me an email listing the lacking features which you find critical. I can't guarantee that I'll add them, but it's always useful to know how many people need what features.

Re:A Backup Solution? by sreitshamer on Sunday January 03, 2010 @07:28PM (#1029393)
http://www.haystacksoftware.com/arq/ would seem to fit his needs for all but the bare-metal restore.

But it's unclear whether he requires an online (offsite) solution or not. For local backup, Time Machine works fine for all but restoring hard links, fifos and devices, which may not matter in his case. You just have to remember to plug in your USB drive, or be near your Time Capsule pretty often.

Re:A Backup Solution? by svrishi on Sunday January 03, 2010 @08:05PM (#1029452)
I have been using http://www.jungledisk.com (acquired by Rackspace over a year back). You pay only for the storage you need (I prefer that over unlimited backup services), you can choose Amazon s3 or Rackspace cloudfiles for storage, client software available on all three platforms works fine and you can encrypt the data with your own passphrase.
Re:A Backup Solution? by CRASCH on Sunday January 03, 2010 @10:37PM (#1029691)
http://www.hybir.com

full online backup

bare metal restore

windows only for now.

Interesting performance advantages can be seen in the screen casts here:

http://www.hybir.com/Action/HybirBackupAction.html

(blatent self promotion)

Re:A Backup Solution? by kylecordes on Sunday January 03, 2010 @09:27PM (#1029586)
The main problem with Time Machine is how badly it "works" with File Vault... backing up the encrypted stripes only, and only when you aren't logged in to your Mac, which in my case is approx 0% of the time.
Re:A Backup Solution? by shpxnvz on Sunday January 03, 2010 @10:45PM (#1029708)
I wouldn't call that working badly - it seems to be about the only reasonable way to handle the situation. I just started working a logout at the end of the day into my schedule and never really thought about it since.

I'm curious what you would rather have it do… backup the content unencrypted, or force a logout every hour to do the backup?

Re:A Backup Solution? by RyanMcGreal on Sunday January 03, 2010 @08:17PM (#1029473)
Back in time + sshfs + cron job is working pretty well for me.
Re:A Backup Solution? by codemechanic on Sunday January 03, 2010 @08:45PM (#1029515)
Try Tonido Backup. http://www.tonido.com/app_backup_home.html.

Works on Windows, Mac and Linux. It is free too.