News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Interview Questions for Hiring Top Performers by dropit_sphere on Monday September 28, 2015 @01:17PM (#10291599)
I have a sneaking suspicion that hiring is like stockpicking: after an initial filter, monkeys with darts would do just as well.

The problem is: if the interviewers are "constantly learning," (and they are, just ask them), then they are consistently making mistakes that the future, more learn-ed version of themselves wouldn't make. To take an example from the article: interviewers are to ask candidates about some time that they used data to make a decision. What if a candidate responds with a story in which they realized the data were pointing the way to a local optimum that the candidate cleverly avoided? To you, smart HN reader, you are perhaps impressed, and tempted to slap the candidate on the back and rejoice in your shared membership in the club of those who've discovered ambiguity ("Complexity, such a bitch, right?"); but if the interviewer but dimly remembers calculus but is proud of themselves for using a sentence with the word "data" in it, then the candidate's response will come off not as an indication of the ability to "ask the right questions," but a sign of non-cooperativeness, "irrational refusal to let decisions be driven by the data," and perhaps intellectual arrogance.

For interviewers, I have no idea what to tell them. For candidates, I can only say: Lie, and then follow through. If they are looking for "grit" but you had a privileged upbringing, make something up and commit to yourself to be grit-ful[0], rather than saying what's in your head, which is "I haven't had much hardship but I get the importance of resilience." If they ask for your greatest weakness[1], say anything but your greatest weakness; instead talk about the difficulty of coping with other peoples' weaknesses ("I don't deal with my father's alcoholism as well as I ought," or "I get impatient with lazy people.").

[0]This is basically what the sales people in your org do, which is why you get those requests.

[1] This is a dishonest question, because there are wrong answers. The only acceptable answers are weaknesses that the interviewer shares; but by making that the only right answer the interviewer is implying that they have the "best" weakness and therefore have no "real" weaknesses. If they don't introspect honestly, why the hell should you? Or, more charitably, which is a better approximation of reality, that you are both about equal on your paths to enlightenment, or that you are an imbecile? Is truth best served by communicating the former through omission, or the latter through facts?

Re:Interview Questions for Hiring Top Performers by matwood on Monday September 28, 2015 @02:46PM (#10292182)
> If they ask for your greatest weakness

"My wife thinks I work too much, but I love writing CRUD apps. I stay awake at night thinking about the most efficient way to get those little pieces of data into webforms used by by a couple dozen people. So yeah, working too much and lack of sleep is my greatest weakness."

Re:Interview Questions for Hiring Top Performers by chad_strategic on Monday September 28, 2015 @03:55PM (#10292742)
-->I have a sneaking suspicion that hiring is like stockpicking: after an initial filter, monkeys with darts would do just as well.

I couldn't agree more. I have probably had more interviews / initial conversations in the last ninety days with tech recruiters. I would say about 95%, knew absolutely nothing about what they where doing, they ask me the generic questions... What are you strengths, weakness? What was a time you where in a bad situation... A lot of times I could figure out that they hadn't read to the bottom of my resume.

Then there is the Tech guy questions: What is OOP? What does it mean when you get this error? What is the difference between PHP 5.6 and PHP 5.5, tell me right now!

I did run across some recruiters that actual read to the bottom of my resume. Usually, they where the ones that figured out I was over qualified for most positions.

The best job I ever had was in the Marine Corps and they never asked me any questions, they where happy to have me sign the contract!

In the meantime, I'm looking for work... http://www.strategic-options.com/resume/?=HN

Re:Interview Questions for Hiring Top Performers by e12e on Monday September 28, 2015 @09:17PM (#10294230)
> In the meantime, I'm looking for work... http://www.strategic-options.com/resume/?=HN

Clearly I'm not the target audience (I'm not in a position to hire, in fact, I'm also looking for work), but I'd be more inclined to read to the end if a) It rendered anything before allowing js, and b) if there was a link (or preferably content) at the top, just listing the bullet points.

Looking at the html-source, I see there's a link to a doc-document buried at the end of the rabbit hole -- I humbly suggest whatever hides in there should also be exported as html, and linked prominently from the landing page.

That said, I'm assuming your reference to people not reading your whole resume is from applications where you've submitted a cover letter + traditional CV?

I should also add, that your resume-site has some impressive points, and good visuals -- I just don't think busy, technical people would want to waste time on that, if they could just see a short list of some of the good things you've done. If those details means nothing to them without pictures, then they're probably not technical enough to be able to make good decisions regarding hiring for technical positions. Personally, I don't think being overlooked by companies that have bad management/HR is a bad thing. I guess it depends who you see as your audience?

Re:Interview Questions for Hiring Top Performers by chad_strategic on Monday September 28, 2015 @10:18PM (#10294391)
Thanks, I agree with most of what you said.

I made the visual resume, mostly for tech recruiters and non technical people / business owners. (Definitely not CTO's), I also use it to see if the tech recruiters actual view my resume, which a lot of time they don't look it at.

Your right, being overlooked by bad management is a blessing in disguise.

Re:Interview Questions for Hiring Top Performers by Bahamut on Monday September 28, 2015 @06:15PM (#10293582)
I'm not sure many would agree that the Marine Corps is the best job they have held :P ...although it certainly teaches you a lot that most people don't get grounded well on & that the tech industry needs a lot more of (handling stress, good leadership, etc.).
Re:Interview Questions for Hiring Top Performers by chad_strategic on Monday September 28, 2015 @04:05PM (#10292813)
Oh, one other thing. Hire Passion, you can always teach skill.
Re:Interview Questions for Hiring Top Performers by lordnacho on Monday September 28, 2015 @04:12PM (#10292869)
Not every organization is good at teaching.
Re:Interview Questions for Hiring Top Performers by chad_strategic on Monday September 28, 2015 @04:34PM (#10292994)
Oh that's for sure. But based on my experience, teaching is also part of leadership. I don't see a lot of leadership in corporate America. I see a lot self interest, hence the outrageous CEO salaries / golden parachutes.
Re:Interview Questions for Hiring Top Performers by gearoidoc on Monday September 28, 2015 @01:51PM (#10291837)
To respond to your point on being asked about weaknesses: I've always taken the honest route. I've given reasons like "hard to find motivation if I don't find the project interesting" and I've found they've gone done quite well (I think I've only been turned down for < 5% of interviews I've done in the past 10 years).

The caveat though: explain to the interviewer that you're being vulnerable. I always make it clear that I hate those "strengths presented as weaknesses" bullshit and then explained that I'm going to be 100% honest. People seem to connect with it.

Re:Interview Questions for Hiring Top Performers by seiji on Monday September 28, 2015 @03:31PM (#10292546)
This is really the only guide to interviewing anybody needs: http://www.smbc-comics.com/?id=3454
Re:Interview Questions for Hiring Top Performers by gearoidoc on Monday September 28, 2015 @05:02PM (#10293170)
Might be taking honesty to an extreme there :)