Re:Forcing suspects to reveal phone passwords is unconstitut...
by dragonwriter on Monday September 28, 2015 @11:20AM
(#10290887)
> I don't see how the contents of a person's brain can be discovered by a court. That's a fact which (so far) can only be known by the defendant. Even if a week ago they showed someone that they knew the password, they still could have forgotten it in the last week.
Mental states -- including knowledge of specific facts, intent, belief, etc. -- are necessary elements of many offenses are determined by courts in the same way as any other facts.
> It'd be like trying to determine with 100% accuracy what a person's favorite color is.
No, its not, because even the "beyond a reasonable doubt" standard for criminal prosecutions is not targeting 100% accuracy, which would be unattainable for any class of facts (not just mental states.)
Mental states -- including knowledge of specific facts, intent, belief, etc. -- are necessary elements of many offenses are determined by courts in the same way as any other facts.
> It'd be like trying to determine with 100% accuracy what a person's favorite color is.
No, its not, because even the "beyond a reasonable doubt" standard for criminal prosecutions is not targeting 100% accuracy, which would be unattainable for any class of facts (not just mental states.)