News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:VP9 encoding/decoding performance vs. HEVC/H.264 by Silhouette on Monday September 28, 2015 @10:26AM (#10290591)
“open standard” just means is that there's a spec which you could use to produce a compatible encoder or decoder.

A published standard has that advantage, but I think when most people talk about "open standards" they are implying a standard that can freely be implemented, in much the same way that for example Open Source software implies more than mere visibility of the source code.

Re:VP9 encoding/decoding performance vs. HEVC/H.264 by acdha on Monday September 28, 2015 @11:01AM (#10290786)
“most” people in certain communities: if you poll open source developers, that's probably true but almost everything you use has components covered by ISO/IETF/ITU-T/etc. standards which do allow licensing at varying levels and all of those people also strongly feel that they work on "open standards” as well.

> in much the same way that for example Open Source software implies more than mere visibility of the source code.

This has a very similar problem: public domain != BSD != Apache != GPL, etc. Depending on who you talk to, only some of those are true open source licenses.

In both cases, the term is too vague to be useful for this level of fine-parsing and you have to talk in more detail about the aspects which you're specifically referring to rather than using a broad term.

Re:VP9 encoding/decoding performance vs. HEVC/H.264 by Silhouette on Monday September 28, 2015 @12:52PM (#10291421)
Fair enough, though the point 'leonatan was trying to make in this case seemed clear to me.
Re:VP9 encoding/decoding performance vs. HEVC/H.264 by acdha on Monday September 28, 2015 @02:23PM (#10292033)
I understood the narrow viewpoint leonatan was coming from but I don't think it's helpful to promulgate personal political viewpoints as universal truth. If you say “HEVC isn't an open standard”, a sizable number of people are going to say “This person has no idea what they're talking about”. If instead you say “HEVC is patent encumbered” you avoid all of that and focus on the core problem.