2) Fair point.
3) Telegram is also a central service, so in that respect it's no better than Silent Circle. WhisperSystems is better in that they make some server source code public. But to be fair to Silent Circle, their offer is much more complete: Voice, Messaging, Encrypted contact storage, and outbound PSTN access.
4) By using SILC, Tor, or GPG broadcasts the fact that you value privacy, which could make you a higher priority. What are you going to do, just send everything in cleartext and hope nobody looks?
3) my point was that telegram was "no better" but has better market penetration, while being essentially the same thing.. why have more standards.
4) this is also true, but it's less real world advertising of that fact, you don't order tor, you don't order GPG, and you don't have a physical device which proudly announces that you do. If you're doing security online right, nobody can tell you're doing it at a glance.
4) You order a privacy tool from Amazon, and you're put on a list. You emit the kind of encrypted traffic that 99% of internet users don't, you also get put on a list. In most cases, there's no difference. I suppose if your threat model requires you physically appear not to care about privacy then it matters. Like maybe you work in a sensitive position and you don't want anyone to think you might exfiltrate data, so you only carry the work provisioned device which logs everything you do.
1) This phone's security features tend to rely on other people having the same phone, which is definitely not a guarantee I can make.
2) This phone (perhaps only this article) doesn't go into detail about how it was secured only that it "was deeply secured" which is too vague for a technical audience.
3) It relies on central services provided by the manufacturer; (why not use Telegram? at least telegram is cross platform).
4) By ordering this phone, it's telling people that I value privacy, which could make me a higher priority target for those that are breaching privacy on a massive scale.
This device does not enhance my privacy, but it gives me all the inconvenience. Now I'd have /another/ user account to worry about and /another/ program to get people to share their details with.
when I think of security I think of PGP (yes, I'm aware the CEO was a producer of PGP) and things like SILC- where it's controlled by users and verified by people you'd like to confer with.