In short, nothing is less in the spirit of HN. I'm sure you didn't do any of the above intentionally, but the trouble with all such problems is that they're the sum of unintentional addends.
Yours on the other hand is condemning behaviour that you yourself appear to accept to be the effects of mental illness and may not be deliberate. And you're doing it to a much larger audience than Terry's banned comments gets.
To me, your comment is a bit like standing up in a crowd, pointing at a mentally ill person and telling us his behaviour is utterly unacceptable before said person has even uttered a word.
It is UGLY.
The gentleman has uttered plenty of words. The first time you take an interest in the eccentric TempleOS it's very confronting and there's no escaping it.
If what you had written was a brief warning about his rants, then that would have been fair enough. But what you wrote was not a warning.
I am similarly entitled to note that you did not write such a warning in whatever style you advocate and neither did anyone else. I'm comfortable standing by my noting his behaviour is unacceptable, because it is.
I have empathy for violent criminals with frontal cortex damage resulting in poor impulse control too, but I don't excuse the violence or say it's ok or pretend it didn't happen and doesn't exist. Do you see the distinction?
For the vast majority of people with severe mental illness that's not true. You don't get to do what you like then claim "lol mental illness".
I probably wouldn't have someone with tourettes making welcoming speech to a group of people who were not aware and whom I really didn't know much about. It's all a bit hypothetical though.
"Among his faults the man uses a lot of racist slurs. I won't and don't excuse that. I don't care how eccentric, imbalanced or in need of better psychiatric care and drugs he is. I wish to point out that his behavior is totally and utterly unacceptable."
- "Among his faults..."
His "fault" is a mental disorder. You have a very 17th century approach to that.
- "I won't and don't excuse that."
Fine, that's your choice. But when you choose to attack someone over their mental state, you become the insensitive, intolerant jerk in the room. Again, you have a choice whether to attack someone over their mental state; your victim didn't choose to be disabled.
- "I don't care how eccentric, imbalanced or in need of better psychiatric care and drugs he is."
I think you make it abundantly clear that you don't care. Again, that's your choice, but it shows exactly what kind of person you are. Would you also not care if it's a loved one who is afflicted with a disorder? Based on what you've said so far, I have to wonder.
- "I wish to point out that his behavior is totally and utterly unacceptable."
Behavior that, again, is out of his control. You are blaming a patient for being sick. That is reprehensible. Yes, he needs help, but what you are doing is the opposite of help, especially since you know for a fact he reads this forum (and in fact I think that is your true motivation for attacking him here).
I've said elsewhere in this thread that (as Robert Sapolsky notes) those with frontal cortex damage to their brains sometimes commit heinous violent crime. That brain damage might be a reason, but doesn't make it ok for them to commit violent crime. It may be completely beyond their control.
His behaviour is unacceptable. I do not accept racist abuse as being acceptable behaviour. Do you?
So you're already calling the guy a sick, mentally disabled, out of control victim? That's all your words -- that's what you think of him.
Why can't he be an asshole, too?
Get over yourself, man. srsly
Why is political correctness so important to you?
1. Because hating entire races of people is a bad thing and it's something we ought to consider along with his achievements.2. Some people would rather not hear/read a bunch of racial slurs so it can be helpful to give others a heads-up if they're thinking about checking out this guy's videos, so they can make their own call.
3. In some ways his unique mindstate is relevant to his work; TempleOS is a monolithic work, created in isolation. His mental illness renders him unwilling/unable to work with others, perhaps contributes to his bizarre racial outbursts, and yet also in many ways makes him able to create TempleOS - something many of us find fascinating.
Please note that nobody here is advocating that Terry shouldn't be allowed to have his say or that threads about TempleOS don't belong on HN.
Personally I really enjoy them and I find TempleOS fascinating.
I'm not sure how I could have been any more explicit there. I explicitly said I enjoy reading news about TempleOS.
So clearly I accept them even though I don't like his racial epithets one bit. They're just one (somewhat unavoidable) facet of the whole TempleOS phenomenon.
I guess I don't understand why people selectively find it so offensive.
There's a big difference between fictional characters in movies and Huckleberry Finn (a book I love!) using slurs and a guy like Terry using slurs in earnest in a non-fiction setting.Huckleberry Finn is a create example, actually. Huck uses the n-word freely, but he is an unreliable narrator, and Mark Twain's stories about Huck often parody the shitty racial attitudes of many white Americans at that time.
To reiterate: do you only decry white racism?
I mean, I totally understand where you're going with this: The world is so unfair to white people. "Straight Outta Compton" is a big box office hit, but Terry's not allowed to have racist diatribes whenever he feels like it, and it's a double standard because they're both using the n-word. Why can black people call each other that as a term of affection, but it's not okay for white people to use the same word as a slur?
Don't worry, you're like the 10 millionth person to go down that line of reasoning and I don't agree with it (bonus points for being even more confusing by throwing sexism into the mix) but I'm also not going to change your mind so it's cool, whatever.
As much as it might please you to be otherwise, that was not my line of reasoning. i asked if you decry racism against whites (or asians, or latinos, or any subgroup) the same, or to the same level that you decry racism against blacks. Your tirade is answer enough.
Still no answer to my question either.
That violates the HN guidelines badly. Please don't do this here. We ban accounts that do it repeatedly.
I've said maybe he doesn't mean it because he's in need of psychological help, perhaps help of a kind that it wholly unavailable at this point in history. This is a tragedy but it doesn't make it acceptable.
Political correctness is something else entirely. Political correctness is it being unacceptable to have dissenting views from the powerful. The phrase comes from, I believe, the China of the 1970s. People who were deemed politically incorrect were treated very badly indeed by a pretty hideous and oppressive regime. It's something quite different from the right to claim my kind are superior to yours while being free of criticism for saying so. It's something different to saying the phrase 'political correctness' as an excuse to be abusive.
I do not object to this man's dissenting political views. He is unwell. He is abusive of people I would wish to make welcome. Look around at the demographic again at any conference, any place of work in this industry. I don't buy arguments that skin melanin or estrogen make for poor engineers, I know some do.
Given I'm not buying that, pointing out abusive behaviour and noting that is pretty awful doesn't seem unreasonable or oppressive of legitimate alternate points of view to me. Does it really to you? I doubt strongly there is any abuse I could direct at you that would make you doubt yourself. Would it were so for those smarter but less confident that you or me.
I am not saying suppress the story, that this story should not be here, just that we shouldn't pretend that awfulness isn't there.
If on the other hand you find racism, of the most gross kind, acceptable as long as it's not directed at a specific person on HN you and I diverge views quite strongly at that point.
(And anyways, Terry's accounts all get hellbanned here, so it's just links and discussion of his cool work. Except for these low-signal threads that will hopefully be detached as off topic.)
>I am not saying suppress the story, that this story should not be here, just that we shouldn't pretend that awfulness isn't there.
How i wish the immediately above statement were applied liberally to the US culture, as opposed to just EuroAmericans and just Males.
All the other quotes are the big markers of a highly subjective point of view being flogged as the only objective point of view. But that's just, like, my opinion man.