Re:Nix the Tricks: Math tricks defeat understanding
by robryk on Sunday September 27, 2015 @10:29AM
(#10286604)
As long as your steps are implications in the reverse direction (from the later to the earlier statement) this is perfectly correct. In most cases I've seen people do that the transformations are actually equivalences, which muddies the waters somewhat.
What is a problem is when people do use reverse-implications that are not equivalences, arrive at something false, and claim that the original equation is false.
Re:Nix the Tricks: Math tricks defeat understanding
by a-nikolaev on Sunday September 27, 2015 @01:09PM
(#10287151)
Yes, I know ) But then this whole derivation now lives in a "special world", where you cannot do all math, but only certain subset.
Your example is cool. I have not seen many exmaples of such logic, but people probably do it too.. )
Re:Nix the Tricks: Math tricks defeat understanding
by robryk on Sunday September 27, 2015 @02:53PM
(#10287485)
The most common example of such logic is multiplying by maybe-zero (transforming a=b into ac=bc) and factoring out a possibly-zero factor (transforming ac!=bc into a!=b).
Re:Nix the Tricks: Math tricks defeat understanding
by arielby on Sunday September 27, 2015 @09:19AM
(#10286398)
That's why you make sure all operations you do are bidirectional.
Re:Nix the Tricks: Math tricks defeat understanding
by a-nikolaev on Sunday September 27, 2015 @01:22PM
(#10287190)
If you are careful and each step gives an equivalent statement, this is correct. For example, if you read math books/papers, whenever such transformation is made, the author usually states that it is equivalent.
However, the problem is that students apply this technique blindly manipulating the formula in any way they can/want. Such carelessness is the real problem.
If they succeed in this procedure, they claim that the original equation they started with was correct too.
Everyone does it, and it takes ages to make them unlearn it.
If somebody is wondering why the technique is incorrect: starting from a false premise, any statement can be proven, including things like 1=1 or 1=0.