News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nix the Tricks: Math tricks defeat understanding by sleepychu on Sunday September 27, 2015 @04:16AM (#10285847)
Cross multiplication is a trick to multiply by the 'reciprocal' of the fraction.

The failing here is that you don't understand why you get the right answer here.

Why is (1/2) / (1/4) = 2? It's because there are 2 quarters in every half, it's not because (1/2) * (4/1) = 2 that's just a 'convenient trick' to get the answer quickly. This is a great idea if your goal is to pass some maths exams which have a fixed format in the near future. It's a terrible idea if you want to be able to apply mathematics to anything.

Re:Nix the Tricks: Math tricks defeat understanding by IanCal on Sunday September 27, 2015 @06:38AM (#10286101)
> Why is (1/2) / (1/4) = 2? It's because there are 2 quarters in every half

That sounds like looking for a "trick" to me, rather than the much simpler generic rearrangement. Trying to cram that phrase into more complex ones I'd start thinking "Wait, how many five eighths are there in seventy sixteenths?"

If the question is "what is (1/2) / (1/4)" and you can't see it, then the idea of rearranging the equation and why rearranging it is OK is pretty important and general.

(5/8) / (70/16) = x

5/8 = 70x / 16

5 . 16/8 = 70x

5 . 2 = 70x

10 = 70x

1/7 = x

That seems simpler to me than "There is one seventh of seventy sixteenths in five eighths" and it requires knowing how basic multiplication and division works, and that the equals sign means that the things on both sides are equal, so if we multiply both sides by the same number or divide by the same number then that's OK. That can then lead into why you need to be careful about values being 0 or why sometimes you have to add ± to an answer.

You can also just generally explore rearrangements, try out different modifications and see if it makes things simpler, go back and try others.

Re:Nix the Tricks: Math tricks defeat understanding by aptwebapps on Sunday September 27, 2015 @05:20AM (#10285964)
Oh, I see. I thought cross multiplying was referring to what you do in order to add or subtract two fractions with different denominators. Should have just looked it up.

The failing here is that you don't understand why you get the right answer here.

By 'you' you mean the putative student mislead by shortcuts, right? I understand perfectly well what's happening with reciprocal multiplication and why it works. ;)

Re:Nix the Tricks: Math tricks defeat understanding by pflats on Sunday September 27, 2015 @02:10PM (#10287324)
Just for clarity on all my responses in these threads, I'm a (minor) contributor to Nix the Tricks and a personal friend and research partner of the author.

Why is (1/2) / (1/4) = 2? It's because there are 2 quarters in every half, it's not because (1/2) x (4/1) = 2 that's just a 'convenient trick' to get the answer quickly.

No, both of these are true. Your logical answer is correct: 1/4 goes into 1/2 twice because there are two quarters in every half. This is how our ancestors conceived division and fractions, and that's how physically dividing things works in the real world. But division is not an independent operation; it's the inverse of multiplication. As plonh mentions downthread, division is, quite literally, defined on a field (like Q) as multiplying by the reciprocal. (1/2) / (1/4) = 2 because (4/1) = (1/4)^-1 and (1/2) * (4/1) = 2. Any other mathematical explanation is simply justifying this fact in more palatable terms.

Re:Nix the Tricks: Math tricks defeat understanding by anthony_d on Sunday September 27, 2015 @12:53PM (#10287095)
I've never heard of most of the tricks mentioned and agree they seem like terrible things to teach, but calling cross multiplication a trick seems bizarre. Cross multiplication is multiplying by the reciprocal. In neither case do you have to understand what you're doing. You can make this complaint about every arithmetic operation.
Re:Nix the Tricks: Math tricks defeat understanding by plonh on Sunday September 27, 2015 @11:51AM (#10286899)
Whaaa? 1/(1/x))=x is absolutely true for all x!=0 in a field.

How does your method explain how to solve "1/2 / 3/4" ? How does talking about how many 4/3 are in 1/2 help?

Re:Nix the Tricks: Math tricks defeat understanding by ashark on Sunday September 27, 2015 @02:34PM (#10287410)
How does it not? There's 2/3 of a 3/4 in a 1/2

(I'm assuming that last sentence was typoed and "talking about how many 3/4 in 1/2" was intended.)