That's not to say that startups are unimportant, just that I don't think anyone would argue it makes sense to replace all research labs with startups. Startups are focused on making money, whereas research is focused with progress in human knowledge.
Secondarily, as public money from governments and money from large corporations dry up, innovation and risks are taken on by other parties. The article completely avoids crowdsourcing such as Kickstarter campaigns, an example of innovation being Oculus and their Rift.
As the cost of innovating decreases, innovation decentralization increases.
> In 2011, Luckey got a dream job working as a technician at the Mixed Reality Lab (MxR) at the University of Southern California's Institute for Creative Technologies (ICT). There, he had a chance to cross deep into VR territory. On Sept. 25, he posted the following on MTBS3D. [These excerpts are condensed and lightly edited.]
He described the experience in a 1500-word narrative titled "Truly immersive (AKA "Holy crap this is real") VR simulation."
via: http://www.popularmechanics.com/technology/gadgets/a12956/pa...
Besides, I was saying that other means have become available as the cost of innovating has been cut, sometimes by orders ot magnitude. Kickstarter, specifically, has replaced a lot of traditional public or large corporation outlets for funding.
Yet, most startups started on shoestrings. Then they got investment from VC firms. These sources of innovation don't come from NSF or Microsoft Research.
And American innovation comes from far more than money. The culture of American innovation is a huge factor, which isn't declining at all.