There's also a non-zero number of companies filing for SR&ED credits and complaining about the onerousness of the audits who, quite frankly, should not be eligible for SR&ED.
Paying devs to build yet another time tracking tool or yet another social network might be contorted to meet the letter of "advancing the state of science by encouraging R&D investment in Canada", but it certainly doesn't meet its spirit.
When you actually are doing appropriate work, it has been reasonably manageable to both get and keep them. I have also, contra the OP, seen this work with 3rd party help on filing, although I wouldn't be surprised if this raises the scrutiny.
It is, as you say, a good program, and I've had fairly reasonable experiences with it when the company in question was
1) well prepared and good about documentation the work. This is the part where a lot of people trip, because you want to document not just how time is spent but on how what it is spent on relates to the larger R&D goals
and
2) Doing work that truly does look SR&ED worthy. This is where third parties seem to specialize in dressing up mundane stuff as ground-breaking science, and why auditors seem to increasingly key in on companies using their services.
In my experience The burden for SR&ED isn't actually too bad if you know what you are doing. Startups typically run into trouble with because they didn't document things as they went, and scramble near filing time.