News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You will fail by jacquesm on Saturday January 02, 2010 @05:19PM (#1027769)
Since I'm mentioned in the post I'll put my $0.02 in the bag here.

The you'll probably fail comment was meant as a reality check because I think that the commercial success of that particular project is doubtful, even if the project itself is a success in terms of execution and use.

Simply because it targets a niche. But I'm really happy Daniel bit the bullet and built it because I think it is a useful thing to have.

The 'Failure is not an option' mentality that some seem to bring to the start-up scene always has me in stitches, because it is really terribly naive to think that somehow you are different and bullet proof. After a couple of failures you begin to get the hang of how to avoid failure in the ways that you've already seen before, and you find new, interesting ways to fail.

But everytime you 'fail', you also simultaneously succeed, you succeed in learning, in educating yourself. Three failed start-ups is probably the equivalent of a badge of merit and positions you very well for a possible success the fourth or the fifth time. It's not just luck, it is a combination of a lot of factors:

  - idea

  - timing
  
  - team

  - execution

  - luck

  - interaction with customers / audience

  - market development
All those have to go your way to hit one out of the park. But at the same time you could be defining success as for instance building a site that attracts more than 'x' visitors per day, or being ramen profitable, or being able to live comfortably of your product.

If I look back across the years my own score is a mixed bag:

  - successful consultancy business

  - successful license business

  - homerun on the webcam stuff

  - a string of 'moderately successful' (as in lots of 
    users but not much $)

  - two major losses

  - a string of failures, most of them small ideas 
    worked out over a period of days, weeks or months.
If you're not prepared to 'take your lumps' the success will also never be yours, so plan ahead, know that if you start a project you can skew the odds a bit in your favor by manipulating those factors that are directly under your control and if you fail make sure you get the maximum mileage of your 'failure' in terms of study points.

Then try again, with the odds more in your favor because of your increased knowledge. One day you will succeed.

Re:You will fail by DanielBMarkham on Saturday January 02, 2010 @05:22PM (#1027771)
Sorry JacquesM -- didn't mean to "out" you. After all, I left off the M!

As usual, you are dead-on target with your comments.

You are also going to owe me dinner for your prediction it won't be a commercial success. Once it is, we're going to sit down and have a nice meal of roasted crow prepared for you to eat :)

Re:You will fail by jacquesm on Saturday January 02, 2010 @05:27PM (#1027779)
You're on ;)

The crow will taste really good, because I really hope that it will work out. Whoever modded you down needs to get a sense of humor installed, or their current one fixed.