Re:Car industry 'buried report revealing US car safety flaws...
by petewailes on Friday September 25, 2015 @06:28AM
(#10277266)
With regards to your first point, they do detonate. It's a question of how.
The main difference is the force with which they go off. In Europe, it's assumed you're wearing a seatbelt, so the force is less, which results in a lower likelihood of injury, compared to a US airbag. Personally, I prefer the European model - wear a seatbelt and you'll be fine, don't and it's on you.
Re:Car industry 'buried report revealing US car safety flaws...
by ska on Friday September 25, 2015 @10:29AM
(#10278344)
Personally, I prefer the European model - wear a seatbelt and you'll be fine, don't and it's on you.
The other way around is kind of insane - you increase the risk for everybody who is using their safety equipment properly, for the benefit of those who can't be bothered.
Re:Car industry 'buried report revealing US car safety flaws...
by amatix on Friday September 25, 2015 @06:34AM
(#10277293)
> I think optional seat belt laws as found in some parts of the US can make some sense there (owing a lot to the fact that there is no single payer healthcare...)
Wat? So because the taxpayer isn't directly picking up the healthcare bill, it's somehow okay to double serious crash-related injuries and deaths[1]?
[1] "Seat belts reduce serious crash-related injuries and deaths by about half." http://www.cdc.gov/motorvehiclesafety/seatbelts/facts.html
Re:Car industry 'buried report revealing US car safety flaws...
by alkonaut on Friday September 25, 2015 @06:44AM
(#10277340)
It's an age-old debate of "is it ok to (risk) hurting yourself?".
Obviously car crashes and other injuries/deaths come at high cost to society even in the case of privatized health insurances, but the cost is at least indirect rather than direct. It's probably even true that the majority of the cost is indirect, and not related to healthcare.
That said, not having a seat belt/helmet law is... well, stupid.
Re:Car industry 'buried report revealing US car safety flaws...
by praptak on Friday September 25, 2015 @11:55AM
(#10278838)
It's pretty direct unless you have a private ambulance. Otherwise it's tying up a valuable shared resource that could be used to save others whose life is in danger for reasons other than own stupidity.
Re:Car industry 'buried report revealing US car safety flaws...
by the-dude on Friday September 25, 2015 @06:57AM
(#10277395)
In the case of seatbelts I think there is more than only thyself. You might be able to control the vehicle better post-crash, preventing injury to bystanders or passengers.
Re:Car industry 'buried report revealing US car safety flaws...
by RyanMcGreal on Friday September 25, 2015 @07:58AM
(#10277604)
Also, if you are belted in you are not a projectile ricocheting around the inside of the car and hitting other passengers.
Re:Car industry 'buried report revealing US car safety flaws...
by jessaustin on Friday September 25, 2015 @10:26AM
(#10278319)
There are always tradeoffs. In this case, risk compensation might lead a seat-belted driver to drive in more reckless fashion.
However: an airbag isn't very effective (and could even be dangerous) without the seat belt, so manufacturers in Europe aren't really required to worry about the safety without seat belts. Effectively the safety regulations say: those with no seat belts are idiots breaking the law and it's not your job to worry about the safety those people. Which is completely sensible.
I think optional seat belt laws as found in some parts of the US can make some sense there (owing a lot to the fact that there is no single payer healthcare...) BUT the reasonable thing to do would be to not force car manufacturers to make cars less safe for those who do wear seat belts.