Re:Is Eclipse JDT dying?
by agumonkey on Thursday September 24, 2015 @05:03PM
(#10274718)
Emacs isn't perfect, and Emacs was the Eclipse of its day.
But it makes a lot of sense so many times. Very pragmatic, extensible simply. It's still thin spaghetti compared to the "sturdiness" of Java/Eclipse. But I've seen the internal long time ago and it was just a fatter model of spaghetti.
Anything in Eclipse requires a lot of efforts, and too many times the original goal gets diluted in the implementation. I said it elsewhere, after spending 2004-2007 on Eclipse, then leaving for Emacs, I recently had to go back to Eclipse, it's not better, git integration is useless, lots of windows for no reason, a very special kind of UI, maybe suitable for people that likes windows and mouse.
It's sad because it comes from the same community that creates the most job friendly systems, so if you wanna play with JEE/Maven/EMF/..., you'll end up needing something like Eclipse, because of this subtle synergy.
But it makes a lot of sense so many times. Very pragmatic, extensible simply. It's still thin spaghetti compared to the "sturdiness" of Java/Eclipse. But I've seen the internal long time ago and it was just a fatter model of spaghetti.
Anything in Eclipse requires a lot of efforts, and too many times the original goal gets diluted in the implementation. I said it elsewhere, after spending 2004-2007 on Eclipse, then leaving for Emacs, I recently had to go back to Eclipse, it's not better, git integration is useless, lots of windows for no reason, a very special kind of UI, maybe suitable for people that likes windows and mouse.
It's sad because it comes from the same community that creates the most job friendly systems, so if you wanna play with JEE/Maven/EMF/..., you'll end up needing something like Eclipse, because of this subtle synergy.