News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Give Google Contributor a try: Pay to remove ads by Spivak on Thursday September 24, 2015 @03:14PM (#10273910)
For people that dislike ads the statement, "I have never ever been positively influenced in any way every by one" is literally a definition because if you purchase anything because of an ad you've been made worse off.

If you were going to buy it anyway then the ad did nothing, if you weren't then you are now worse off as you bought something you wouldn't have otherwise -- you've been manipulated.

From this there is no such thing as a positive ad.

Also, he didn't say that ads don't work on him, they certainly do but they're not having the desired effect which makes them worthless to the advertiser. Sure, they get brand recognition but if you consciously make an effort to avoid brands which advertise to you and recommend that others avoid the brand too then you've actually cost the advertiser money, making the ad worthless.

Re:Give Google Contributor a try: Pay to remove ads by greiskul on Thursday September 24, 2015 @04:02PM (#10274272)
But what if you weren't going to buy it because you were not aware it existed? When you see an ad for an interesting movie and decide to check it out, you go watch it, and love it, are you really worse off? Maybe you see an ad for a new restaurant and decide to check it out. Are you worse off? Aren't these examples of positive ads?
Re:Give Google Contributor a try: Pay to remove ads by Nursie on Thursday September 24, 2015 @04:14PM (#10274358)
I like to operate by word of mouth, sometimes online searches (and I'll take reviews over ads any day, even when searching) and by stumbling across things.
Re:Give Google Contributor a try: Pay to remove ads by RodericDay on Thursday September 24, 2015 @04:32PM (#10274489)
What if you see the ad, and decide to check the movie out, and it's terrible - a waste of your time and money? What if you see a slick ad for a restaurant, and it turns out the restaurant spends more money on ads than on being a good restaurant, and it is a waste of money? Are you better off?
Re:Give Google Contributor a try: Pay to remove ads by softawre on Thursday September 24, 2015 @04:54PM (#10274654)
Wow. He was saying they could be positive. Of course you can come up with a counter-example...
Re:Give Google Contributor a try: Pay to remove ads by RodericDay on Thursday September 24, 2015 @05:24PM (#10274854)
Which is why it is ridiculous to approach the situation from a "what if..." perspective. We should approach it from net expected benefit, else everyone gets to pretend they are the one true purveyor of good and classy ads.
Re:Give Google Contributor a try: Pay to remove ads by ionised on Friday September 25, 2015 @11:59AM (#10278871)
> Also, he didn't say that ads don't work on him, they certainly do but they're not having the desired effect which makes them worthless to the advertiser. Sure, they get brand recognition but if you consciously make an effort to avoid brands which advertise to you and recommend that others avoid the brand too then you've actually cost the advertiser money, making the ad worthless.

This is exactly how I feel ads affect me. If I see an ad, I'm inclined to avoid the company advertising that product or service to me in future.

Re:Give Google Contributor a try: Pay to remove ads by r00fus on Thursday September 24, 2015 @07:10PM (#10275423)
That's not exactly true.

If I'm looking for, say, a bluetooth speaker, find an ad that looks interesting (of course I do a bit of product research), that may of more utility to me than the "frustrated, and did not buy anything" option.

However, things like Taboola are a cancer on the internet. Distracting and useless.

Re:Give Google Contributor a try: Pay to remove ads by jarfil on Friday September 25, 2015 @07:19AM (#10277475)
If I'm looking for a bluetooth speaker, or metal snips (got ones the other day), I will look for:

1. Specs 2. Reviews 3. Teardown 4. Product comparisons

Ads just don't give me any of that, the landing pages too often don't even have the specs, and I am never going to choose a brand name if their specs/reviews/teardown/price is worse than any other brand's or non-brand product's.

The only ads that "could", "maybe", "in theory" work on my are from Amazon, since free 1-day shipping is a cool thing... except I already search Amazon when I'm looking for a product, and by the time they get to show me ads about it, I've already made a purchase and are no longer interested.