News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Give Google Contributor a try: Pay to remove ads by kbenson on Thursday September 24, 2015 @02:11PM (#10273414)
My point is that it isn't always about buying habits, at least not immediately (and sometimes never).

Sometimes advertising is about awareness. Sometimes that's brand awareness, but it's also issue awareness. There are ads about social issues. They are often about making sure you are aware of the organization that put the ad out in case you want to get involved/help financially, but often it's also just to raise awareness about the issue.

In what way is a site showing an ad about children going hungry in America (as Hulu used to play quite often) and him not clicking on it scamming the organization that put the ad out? In what way is his blanket rejection of the ad before actually seeing it making helping that organization?

As I said, a very naive view.

Re:Give Google Contributor a try: Pay to remove ads by Nursie on Thursday September 24, 2015 @02:15PM (#10273460)
>> In what way is a site showing an ad about children going hungry in America (as Hulu used to play quite often) and him not clicking on it scamming the organization that put the ad out?

It's one 'view' (well page-load, because I'm not going to view it regardless) that's going to get them nowhere that they don't have to pay for.

>> In what way is his blanket rejection of the ad before actually seeing it making helping that organization?

Again, they don't have to pay for me to completely ignore them.

Are you trying to argue that I should watch all advertising that comes my way in case some of it is socially responsible?

I'm not sure who has the more naive view here...

Re:Give Google Contributor a try: Pay to remove ads by kbenson on Thursday September 24, 2015 @02:31PM (#10273584)
> Are you trying to argue that I should watch all advertising that comes my way in case some of it is socially responsible?

No, but I think your view on advertising and the content it supports is hypocritical (because you still accept the desired content), so I thought casting it in light of a hopefully less nefarious cause might cause you to look at it more objectively.

The naivety I reference is specifically in your belief that you can correctly predict the desires of multiple large and small complex business entities in their goal to advertising in front of you, and make decisions in their best interest that are against their expressed desire.

There are many arguments for ad-blockers that can be put forth, but I don't believe taking the moral high-ground is a valid one.

Edit: s/arguments against/arguments for/

Re:Give Google Contributor a try: Pay to remove ads by TeMPOraL on Thursday September 24, 2015 @02:36PM (#10273625)
> The naivety I reference is specifically in your belief that you can correctly predict the desires of multiple large and small complex business entities in their goal to advertising in front of you, and make decisions in their best interest that are against their expressed desire.

I think there is nothing to predict here - they have no goal towards 'Nursie, or any other particular viewer. Advertising on-line is done by carpet-bombing the whole Internet with cheap ads, hoping that enough people get hit.

Re:Give Google Contributor a try: Pay to remove ads by kbenson on Thursday September 24, 2015 @07:55PM (#10275619)
How does that affect the argument in any way? They are willing to pay to have this add viewed by a visitor on a site at a particular time, and the site is willing to display it along with the content. Their goal, in the broadest and most general sense is to have the ad displayed. You can't assume they are trying to get you to buy something by clicking on it (it may not even be available yet), you can't assume they are trying to have you buy something later (it could be a brand-awareness campaign where you may not have a need for what they are selling, but you may tell someone who does), you can't assume they are even selling a product or service (they may not be, it could be a social issue awareness ad).

I stand by my assertion that thinking you know exactly what the intention of an ad that was is naive. And that's before considering that you wouldn't even see it in this case, you would just block it and assume blindly.

Re:Give Google Contributor a try: Pay to remove ads by Nursie on Thursday September 24, 2015 @02:38PM (#10273646)
>> No, but I think your view on advertising and the content it supports is hypocritical (because you still accept the desired content)

I have said I will be happy to include a header in my http requests that says I will not render ads, and I already am happy to pay for content in other media. I will now explore that on the web.

At the moment, however, I request content from web servers and they send it to me. I make no guarantees implied or otherwise about what I will do with it or how I will render it.

>> The naivety I reference is specifically in your belief that you can correctly predict the desires of multiple large and small complex business entities in their goal to advertising in front of you,

They want my money. I'm well aware of this much.

>> and make decisions in their best interest that are against their expressed desire.

Well perhaps not, but in the simple case I will repeat - if I notice you're advertising your brand at me, I will not buy your stuff.

>> There are many arguments against ad-blockers that can be put forth, but I don't believe taking the moral high-ground is a valid one.

There are very many arguments for ad-blockers that do occupy the moral high-ground. Advertising is manipulative and it's not immoral to block these attempts at manipulation.

Re:Give Google Contributor a try: Pay to remove ads by kbenson on Thursday September 24, 2015 @07:46PM (#10275583)
I do not accept that advertising is manipulative. I accept that many forms of communication, it can be.

> Advertising is manipulative and it's not immoral to block these attempts at manipulation.

My argument has never been that you shouldn't be able to control what's presented to you, just that if it's part of an exchange, if you reject one part, you shouldn't get the other. and I think casting yourself as actually helping the advertiser in this situation is a specious argument.

Re:Give Google Contributor a try: Pay to remove ads by Nursie on Friday September 25, 2015 @05:41AM (#10277136)
Well I disagree, because I take against advertising so much that by making me see it they would be doing themselves a disservice, and costing themselves money in the process.

And I'm sorry but I do think advertising is manipulative through and through. That's pretty much the whole point.

Re:Give Google Contributor a try: Pay to remove ads by kbenson on Friday September 25, 2015 @02:02PM (#10279647)
> And I'm sorry but I do think advertising is manipulative through and through. That's pretty much the whole point.

So is all communication. That friend you tells you about his morning, or some current event? He's expecting to elicit a particular type of response. We don't generally care too much, because we attribute good, or at least harmless intentions to their communication. We manipulate the emotions of those around us as a secondary communication channel.

Advertising is communication as well. The difference is that we often adopt an adversarial stance when dealing with it, because while most advertising is about the company selling you something and mostly harmless (if annoying) it's still informative of the product, but some advertising is outright misleading and can confuse the issue. Advertising isn't bad because it tries to manipulate you, but it can be bad when that manipulation is to get you to do something that isn't in your best interests (otherwise it ranges from helpful, through useless, and to annoying).

Advertising can be useful and helpful. It helps people determine what is available in the market and make a decision on what to buy or what to research. The name of a store on it's exterior, and the name of a site at the top are both advertising, and useful. You may have decided that you think this trade in information is not worth your time, and that's fine, but I reject any argument so simplistic as to say advertising is bad and possibly immoral because it's manipulative. It's too simplistic to have a meaningful relation to reality in this case, and thus has no place in this discussion, IMO.