News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is It Possible to Achieve Equitable Equity for Startup Em... by hapless on Thursday September 24, 2015 @01:42PM (#10273183)
I don't think many employees have a 1 in 2000 chance of a $10M outcome. I'm OK with the 0.005% odds on a multi-billion exit. Let's stick with that. The problem isn't the odds, it's the returns. As another article on HN pointed out, currently, 100% of billion dollar startups (every single "unicorn") have significant investor liquidation preferences.

As a result, for a non-founder, a 1% early-stage stake, at the exit of a billion dollar "unicorn", is quite likely to come out as a nice annual bonus at a "normal" firm: $10k to $100k. The one-two punch of dilution and liquidation preference eats up employee equity.

a %0.005 chance at $100k comes out to an expected value of $500. Even after we consider the odds, that $100k is four years in the future, with a one year cliff and a lot of individual risks involved, unconnected to the firm's fortunes. The present value is conceivably much lower than the expected value of $500. It's essentially nothing.

--

As a postscript: There's nothing intrinsically wrong with offering equity stakes with a negligible present value. Clearly, startups still find talent that satisfies them. The system is working.

Re:Is It Possible to Achieve Equitable Equity for Startup Em... by alain94040 on Thursday September 24, 2015 @01:50PM (#10273251)
As a result, for a non-founder, a 1% early-stage stake in the exit of a billion dollar "unicorn" is quite likely to come out as a nice annual bonus at a "normal" firm: $10k to $100k. The one-two punch of dilution and liquidation preference eats up employee equity.

Your math has to be completely off. If you started with 1% of a company, even after a lot of dilution and liquidation preferences, a $1B exit will give you north of $3M. Not $10k to $100k.

Re:Is It Possible to Achieve Equitable Equity for Startup Em... by hapless on Thursday September 24, 2015 @01:57PM (#10273309)
It is entirely possible for a $1B exit to leave you with literally $0.

Let's say your company has accepted $500 million in funding, with a 2x LP, at a $1 billion valuation. The company exits for $1 billion. Investors take a their 2x LP, for the entire $1 billion. Founders and employees get $0, despite a "billion dollar exit."

This is the trivial case. It is not even considering dilution, founders retention of "preferred" shares, the complicated ownership structures that can result from 3-5-10 rounds of funding, or lengthy employee lockouts after an IPO.

Re:Is It Possible to Achieve Equitable Equity for Startup Em... by aetherson on Thursday September 24, 2015 @05:02PM (#10274706)
Nobody raises $500M with a 2x liquidation preference at a $1B valuation. And if they did, they wouldn't exit at $1B. This is a complete fantasy scenario.
Re:Is It Possible to Achieve Equitable Equity for Startup Em... by mahyarm on Thursday September 24, 2015 @07:44PM (#10275575)
Well there is one company relatively recently that has raised $300M on a $1B valuation. I don't know the liquidation preference, but it happens.
Re:Is It Possible to Achieve Equitable Equity for Startup Em... by aetherson on Thursday September 24, 2015 @11:48PM (#10276282)
I guarantee you their liquidation preference is not 2x (or indeed above 1x). And 30% is not 50%. Even if for some unfathomable reason the liquidation preference was 2x, and even if for some even more unfathomable reason the company promptly exited at $1B, that would leave $400M to be distributed to everyone else who had stock.
Re:Is It Possible to Achieve Equitable Equity for Startup Em... by aetherson on Thursday September 24, 2015 @05:00PM (#10274695)
Investor liquidation preferences should not affect the value of employee shares if the valuation of the company has gone up steadily. I mean, if you have a "$1B exit" from a company that raised money at a $10B valuation, then, well, yes. But that's not really a $1B exit.