It's a big market - and there are vendors who specialize in fake accounts - that means there's a lot of interest/money in being able to fake popularity.
The future ground of all social networks is Astroturf.
[1] http://www.dailykos.com/story/2013/06/23/1218189/-HBGary-Pal...
Could explain some of the spike.
Indeed. I was working for a Facebook gaming company around 2010. Through the "recruit a friend" bonuses and "have X friends click this" mechanics, there were incentives to simply make fake accounts to obtain the goals. We looked at our users and figured about half were fake Facebook accounts. I have to imagine the numbers for other companies, like Zynga, were similar, as they used the same mechanics.
If you actually read the article, the Heineken advertiser's response is:
> “It was like we’d been throwing our money to the mob,” Amram says. “As an advertiser we were paying for eyeballs and thought that we were buying views. But in the digital world, you’re just paying for the ad to be served, and there’s no guarantee who will see it, or whether a human will see it at all.”
This is true. I'm more thinking along the lines of "we have 1 billion active users!"
>you can still do demographic targeting, no?
This I'm not so sure about. Some targeting, sure. But the fake profiles make it more difficult, since the demographic data is also fake.
> Indeed. I was working for a Facebook gaming company around 2010. Through the "recruit a friend" bonuses and "have X friends click this" mechanics, there were incentives to simply make fake accounts to obtain the goals. We looked at our users and figured about half were fake Facebook accounts. I have to imagine the numbers for other companies, like Zynga, were similar, as they used the same mechanics.
You're NOT talking about the same thing.
You think similar networks aren't abusing search?
A 'fake' or API-driven search is different than a fake social networking profile and it's associated bots.
Instagram, with some of its fake accounts, now with its claimed 400million accounts, overlap with facebooks.
Boris Boris sells the contents of the iframe he bought on Doubleclick to Myspace (as "paid traffic"), which in-turn lets Myspace sell it on video exchanges.
Google don't care even a little bit about this, since they still make a fortune off the Boris's of the world.
The reporter originally claimed there were something like 5,000,000 women bots and 12,000 real women. Turns out the numbers were more like the other way around.
I'm not linking to her article admitting her mistake as it's pathetic how she tries to cover up her mistake with more allegations based on incomplete data.
This is a perfect example of why blogs shouldn't be relied on as news sources, and you're the one asking me for citations? Where are your citations?
This is not a convincing argument in any way at all. You're behaving indistinguishably from someone just making shit up.
http://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/statement-from-avid-...
This refutation was widely reported, although unsurprisingly not as much as the original cockup.
While quite a lot more women used the service then the analyst initially thought, it is still true that AM did a lot to encourage men to pay them based on contact with fake accounts, and it apparently worked: http://www.gizmodo.co.uk/2015/09/one-chart-that-shows-how-mu...
Ashley Madison was still a sad, exploitative scam.
Ironically, Google the term "buy facebook accounts". This is the elephant in the room nobody wants to talk about in the social networking space. 50% or more of the social networking profiles out there could be fake given bots, systems and marketplaces that auto generate this stuff in mass amounts to spam and siphon ad dollars.
Another way to look at this is based on how and why virus makers target PCs along with how many PCs are currently affected.
Not many fake 'searches' are happening compared to fake bots and social networking profiles. Yet another reason why Google makes $70 billion per year.