Re:Mathematical model suggests London Underground may be 'to...
by sandworm101 on Thursday September 24, 2015 @11:22AM
(#10272105)
This analysis seems based on preventing congestion. But congestion, while ugly, isn't a bad thing. What matters is total journey time.
Imagine if you replaced all the trains with trek-style teleporters. Rather than 100 people all getting onto a train and being whisked away, they would all wait in a line outside these devices. That would be an increase in congestion, more people standing around waiting rather than moving. But if the teleporters get them to their destinations faster nobody cares that they had to wait in line.
It's a matter of perspective. The city/transport planners see people standing around not moving as a bad thing. But the people don't care. Standing on the slow train or standing in the line waiting for the fast train is all the same to them. What works best for the people isn't the an elegant system of slow trains to ensures nobody ever stops, where nobody ever suffers the evil congestion. What works best for them is getting to work as fast as possible. If that means crowds at bottleneck where in-feed is slightly faster then out-feed so be it. Slowing things down, having more people spend more time standing in trains rather than on platforms, doesn't help them get to work faster.
Imagine if you replaced all the trains with trek-style teleporters. Rather than 100 people all getting onto a train and being whisked away, they would all wait in a line outside these devices. That would be an increase in congestion, more people standing around waiting rather than moving. But if the teleporters get them to their destinations faster nobody cares that they had to wait in line.
It's a matter of perspective. The city/transport planners see people standing around not moving as a bad thing. But the people don't care. Standing on the slow train or standing in the line waiting for the fast train is all the same to them. What works best for the people isn't the an elegant system of slow trains to ensures nobody ever stops, where nobody ever suffers the evil congestion. What works best for them is getting to work as fast as possible. If that means crowds at bottleneck where in-feed is slightly faster then out-feed so be it. Slowing things down, having more people spend more time standing in trains rather than on platforms, doesn't help them get to work faster.