Re:One of BMW's cars doesn't pass European emissions tests
by Shivetya on Thursday September 24, 2015 @09:41AM
(#10271493)
I am quite sure this won't be confined to strictly diesel cars soon. All cars emissions will likely need to be tested to insure the majority of possible configurations comply. There may even be cases where actual bugs in software lead to bad results and not actual malicious coding
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:One of BMW's cars doesn't pass European emissions tests
by Amorymeltzer on Thursday September 24, 2015 @09:57AM
(#10271583)
The one good thing that may come from all this is a potential opening of code. Maybe not in the open-source kind of way, but hopefully at least in the auditing-so-we-know-you're-not-lying kind of way.
Re:One of BMW's cars doesn't pass European emissions tests
by jhugg on Thursday September 24, 2015 @10:06AM
(#10271632)
It honestly sounds cheaper just to subject these cars to randomized spot testing than to expect people to review this code all that well. Reviewing code is expensive in either time or money, and a lot of this code exists in the world.
Re:One of BMW's cars doesn't pass European emissions tests
by Amorymeltzer on Thursday September 24, 2015 @10:24AM
(#10271759)
The VW stuff was found by testing 30 cars 30 times each, and even then it wasn't a slam dunk. Besides, by then, it's too late.
Re:One of BMW's cars doesn't pass European emissions tests
by mikeash on Thursday September 24, 2015 @09:47AM
(#10271519)
Except for EVs. I think we can trust that Nissan LEAFs, Teslas, and similar are not lying about their emissions! I wonder if this will give them a boost in the market.
Re:One of BMW's cars doesn't pass European emissions tests
by thoastbrot on Thursday September 24, 2015 @09:58AM
(#10271589)
I wonder which industry is the dirtiest: power or fuel processing? (if you include that)
Re:One of BMW's cars doesn't pass European emissions tests
by mikeash on Thursday September 24, 2015 @10:42AM
(#10271857)
Even when an EV is powered entirely by coal power, it's still on par with a decent gasoline vehicle. Add any other power to the mix (it's rare to have a power grid that's exclusively coal) and you do better than traditional cars, even when said traditional cars aren't gaming the system.
We can probably be confident that power plants aren't cheating, because they're so few in number and are therefore much easier to monitor. And we can be highly confident that solar, wind, nuclear, hydro, etc. aren't lying about their emissions.