Re:Volkswagen’s Diesel Fraud Makes Critic of Secret Code a P...
by pbhjpbhj on Thursday September 24, 2015 @07:41AM
(#10271036)
>some ECU code(not safety relevant, thankfully) //
What parts of the running of an automobile engine aren't safety relevant?
Sounds like "oh we made the stock for that shotgun from cheap, brittle plastic as the stock isn't safety relevant; how were we to know that it would crack and embed itself in someones shoulder?".
You're right that the primary issue here is deceit but the issue of closed source code in such systems is how that deceit was possible [edit, should probably say "facilitated that deceit" as the deceit would still be possible, just harder and move discoverable with open source]; and that leads to questions of safety as if companies will screw over the environment against the democratic legislation then they're unlikely to be mindful of other morally negative consequences.
Re:Volkswagen’s Diesel Fraud Makes Critic of Secret Code a P...
by Too on Monday September 28, 2015 @03:30PM
(#10292540)
Infotainment, air conditioning, etc. There are many many more ECUs in a car than just the one in the engine.
The exact same thing happens in the car industry.
> I assume the car industry has a similar set of rules and the problem is not a lack of rules, but a lack of enforcement.
Bingo! Right now I'm staring at some ECU code(not safety relevant, thankfully) that looks like it's been written by a monkey, but I'm a new addition to the team, have no authority here yet and we have to ship it like yesterday.
Guess what will happen.
Truth be told, for safety relevant applications, I've seen the code and it's quite good. And the issue in this case is not that the software was badly built, it's that it was built with deceit on their mind.